The Crazy Tomato

899 W 3rd St, Williamsport - 17701
127 reviews
Burgers Pizza Sandwich Shop
(570) 567-7528

Cheesecake ordered. This was first time. Bun was"soggy", had to try eating cut up. too wet to pick up in hand. Would be better served on toasted bun. Will try again. Thanks ?

Went there today for the first time ever and I’m kinda mad at myself for waiting this long to try the place out because I will be back again to try some of the other items they have on the menu

I’ve only had this a handful of times over the years, but there’s absolutely nothing to complain about. Cute little place - great prices to portion sizes - and the food is really good! Besides…where else can you get Funnel Cake Fries!?

I ate at the crazy tomato yesterday. I haven’t been there since they moved to W. 3rd St. the food was awesome! Very happy with especially the funnel cake fries. That’s a cure for any sweet tooth. I had the crazy club sandwich. Oh Lord it was huge so bring your appetite! It was so delicious! I highly recommend to anyone

We ordered 2 Crazy Club Sandwiches and it over 45 minutes to receive our order. The couple seated behind us ended up waiting so long they had both of there entire orders boxed up to go and left the restaurant without dining in. I went to get small to go box from the counter and the entire staff was hidden in the back as a result it took 10 minutes for someone to realize I was standing up front waiting for a small to go box.I truly wish the best for this restaurant after all there has been 3 previously owned restaurants at this same location prior to this one moving in that have bit the dust for almost the same reasons. Word of mouth travels real fast in Williamsport.

Have not been there since they moved to new location … our to go order was placed in person at 12:05 pm at the restaurant and food did not come out to us until 12:50. Ordered a tuna fish sandwich a sub and wrap. What upset us most was people that came in after us were being served before us.When people are on a tight lunch schedule they should tell you at time of order it is going to be 45 min till food can come out. Food was good but execution of service is poor.

Delicious food, especially homemade potato chips. A bit pricey but clean, pleasant atmosphere and service. People must love it. It was very busy. Waited about 20 minutes for eat-in order.

Okay, I don't post reviews often, but this place is AWESOME! We stopped on a road trip with kids and it was the perfect stop. Great food for kids and adults at great prices! I had to look up to see if it was a chain bc i was hoping there was one close to us! LOVED IT!!

so much bigger now... and the food is the best

Excellent Food First time eating There.Everything is Fresh.Nice and clean inside The building.Crazy tomato workers u be seeing me again.I be buying my steak sandwiches There for now on.