We loved eating dinner here! Our first fine dining experience and it did not disappoint. Our waitress (Olivia I think) was attentive and very kind! We got the Crispy Hen dish and the Spinach Gnudi. Both were delicious, but the pasta and sauce in the chicken dish were exceptional. We also got a delicious creme brûlée!
Back in the 90's I frequently took my mother here for lunch and she loved it. She also loved the prices, (she was from Long Island) and always enjoyed good food and was a fantastic cook herself. Throughout the years I have dined here with family and friends and always had the best food served by the most competent and friendly staff. This is definitely one of my favorite places to eat and it just keeps getting better.
Delicious everytime. Cannot beat the atmosphere.
We certainly enjoyed a family dinner here. The building is nicely restored and shows this classic town well. Good food and drinks. Service good as well. I’d go back
What a lovely dining experience! Formal yet laid back. All the dishes were executed beautifully! The entrees including steaks, pasta and seafood were all superb. The starters were amazing as well! Top shelf beverages and spirits! 5☆ Staff was friendly and well versed also!
It was a bit shocking to realize I've been going to the Peter Herdic House Restaurant for 15 years. Most recently they helped us accommodate for 15 people for dinner. Hannah and Hayley are amazing bar tenders. It is rare that I'll deviate from a Caesar salad and Filet, medium rare with peppercorn sauce. My deviation is usually to Caesar salad with filet tips...! Honestly in 15 years, their Caesar salad and croutons are unrivaled and the steak is simply heaven every time. I truly recommend checking this restaurant out if you are in Williamsport.
This was our 1st time dining here. We usually choose a fine dining restaurant on our anniversary. The food was so delicious, this is now my FAVORITE place to eat on our special occasions.
The food was delicious! Our waitress was so sweet and attentive. The atmosphere was so welcoming. We are looking forward to going again! I had the crab cakes and they were so delicious, All Crab!
A very nice restaurant and we are pleased with our experience. The wine, soup, and meals were great. The sweet potatoes with my meal were a little too done, I’m unsure if it was purposefully done that way or not. Either way everything else was delicious. The service was friendly and attentive.
Great old house transformed into a restaurant. Beautiful decor. Food was fantastic. Drinks were yummy too.