Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

1825 E 3rd St, Williamsport - 17701
226 reviews
Italian Salad Soup
(570) 321-9250

Went here for my birthday with my family. Didn't have to wait long which made it nice to be seated. Now the real train wreck begins...-Had a new waitress who didn't pay any attention to our orders.-She also was not very attentive to her tables. (i.e. checking for refills or seeing if we wanted more bread, didn't really know the specialties.)The waitress also screwed up one of the orders. Also tried to make it sound like it was "Our" fault when she REPEATED EVERYTHING PERFECTLY DOWN THE LINE!-Had to wait on my drink because we had another waitress bring us a salad and when we asked for refills mine had to wait because she couldn't get it due to it being on the original waitresses "Card". (I had Angry Orchird)-the Food was less then good honestly. The chicken Alfredo I ordered didn't have enough sauce and one of my party didn't even get chicken with his.-the waitress had a bit of an attitude saying "You should of told me sooner" when she was gone for almost 45 minutes. So hard to actually "say" anything at all. When your waitress and staff is no where near by.-when we told them we wanted boxes to go she never brought them out and again said "you should of said something" after saying she would go get them.Over all the service was....> a nightmare.>unattentive>had poor communication skills>treated the customer less then respectful toward getting our food.>was not well informed or trained very well (again not going to roll out she was new but your working with a lot of people and you have make sure your both ok and good at treating customers with respect, dignity and keeping a level head at all times.)>the food was... just less then good.>they never took the chicken off the order like they said they would. (This was do to a error on the waitress taking the order.)>the only redeeming quality was the bread sticks... that's it.So to be fairly honest if they actually cleaned up their training, took better care of their customers and paid closer attention to the ORDERS when delivering them/preparing them I'd rate this alot hire. It used to be my favorite resteraunt but recently in the past few times eating here I feel it's gone down hill fast. It saddens me because I did really like their food at one point. So if your going to eat here make sure your ready for whatever happens.

I got stabbed here. I’m coming back next weekend but I got stabbed here… so, come at your own discretion

Ordered chicken scampi. The chicken was over browned, it was served with spaghetti instead of angel hair pasta, the sauce was a red sauce not a creamy white sauce. I was very disappointed as I had not been there since covid and chicken scampi is my favorite meal. Will not be going back to Williamsport Pa Olive Garden anytime soon. I will however give other Olive Gardens a chance before giving up on them completely.

I ordered a family style meal to go. The lasagna was great. Everything tasted good. They were 10min late getting it out to me, but in the end gave me twice as many breadsticks than I ordered... Which I was not sad about ??

2 stars because of togo… Why can’t I use two gift cards on the app? I’d love a response from the owner. I took off the tip because I thought it was ridiculous. I work at togo for another restaurant and that’s the dumbest thing ever. I did consider calling in but I’ve called in before and no one was any help.

Server was friendly. Food was very good.

Love the food and margaritas.. could've had better service but our waiter was used all over the restaurant, not his fault. Had a good time regardless ❤

Olive Garden is our favorite go to Italian food restaurant. We often go order an eat in entree, then take home a couple of the $5 special. Our waitress was so much fun and enjoyable. Very attentive and friendly.

Way too much employee chatter at the front door kiosks. My take out dinner was dropped on the floor. Its lid stayed on, thank goodness. The girls were too busy talking to pay attention to the container.

As always, the food and the staff were amazing. However, the building itself is starting to show some age and the cleanliness is not far behind. It was not impressed with the bathrooms and how unhygienic they were