Where to start? I live about 2 hrs away from this place and stumbled upon it quite out of pure luck. I sat and looked at the reviews and decided to try it out. I ordered a small regular Stromboli with mushrooms. Within the 12 mins or less that it took from order time to end I saw everything I needed to. I've been in a lot of pizza shops all over and have not encountered a place like this. I do mean that in the best way. The staff there is the friendliness I've encountered, very welcoming also. The place is very clean. The products I've seen are of fresh quality. As I sat I watched what seemed to be a regular customer talking and joking with the staff like family. As she walked past me to leave she smiled and said how great the people are. I told her it was my first time there. She smiled and raved about the staff and the food and told me I made the right choice. I wish I could thank her now for being right. My food was out of this world. Crispy and buttery. The sauce was savory not like the typical sugar packed sweet sauces many use in pa. Hats off to everyone there and yes I'll drive 2 hrs again from time to time for that food and the people. Thank you
I love this place it's a very excellent place to dine and order out for delivery. They're the most pleasant and spiritual people I've meant since I've moved to Williamsport!! ? God bless this establishment!!
Long Island Pizza is the place for real pizza. For a pizza purist like me, this old-school pizza is what you are looking for in Williamsport. The staff is friendly and helpful. On our way out the door, the gentleman making the pizza thanked us for coming. Nice touch.If there is a pizza joint in Heaven, I'll bet the pizza tastes as it came from Long Island Pizza.For anyone who believes the “Hut” serves authentic pizza, I'm sorry, but you are beyond help. Treat yourself, try this place for the best pizza in Williamsport.
Newish to Williamsport but in my 31 years I've never seen such amazing customer service come from this pizza place. One of a kind no doubt. The owner and the employees were amazing completely awesome and filled with personality. The customers in the store were even great. If you want some good pizza wings and a spirit pep up come here you're not going to be disappointed. 10 out of 5 if I could guys n gals thank you for the experience.
Been a customer of this particular pizza/sub resteraunt for a few years. It's a family owned/ran Pizza Shop that offers a great choice selection to anyone looking to get a quick lunch or dinner.Their fairly quick about getting your order to you. They even offer deserts which some are seasonal so keep that in mind. They mainly deal with pizzas and subs as far as food goes but they do branch out to other things such as hot dogs and BBQ sandwiches.Now as far as the crew goes the owner is rare breed because he tries to get to know his customers. As I said that's truly rare now a days. He'll be the first to welcome ya, ask how you are? Ect. He loves creating conversations with his customers new and old. He even makes a habit of trying to learn names when possible.His kids help him run it (not sure if all of them do) and their just as decent as he is. When you first walk in you'll be greeted with good music and heart felt hello or welcome!The food it's self is great though I wish the subs were a little bigger but outside of that I honestly have no complaints. Never had a bad experiance as far as food or representation goes for this little pizza shop.the prices are also very fair. I rarely ever go beyond $30 for food here.It's in the Hepburn plaza right by Rent-A-Center can't miss it. If your looking for a place that serves a goof pizza and welcomes you like family then honestly can't go wrong here!
I've lived in Williamsport for 3 years now and this is by far the best pizza in town. The dough is the best part.
I looked to contact you privately, your number is only listed, wanted to email. Today was my first time coming to your shop. I ordered a slice of plain pizza and I know every ones taste are different. My slice had way to much oregano. I like oregano but honestly after one bite I could not eat it. My b f took a bite and did not like it either. The sauce cup had way to much oregano in it as well. Maybe it is just us, or maybe someone put way to much in it. I wanted it to be crisp but the young guy showed it to me to see if it was crisp enough and I said yes but it wasn't, if it went back in the already burned top of the cheese would of been burned more and inedible. Star based on our taste or a possible mistake???
We look forward to ordering from Long Island every Friday night. Everything we have ordered has been amazing, the New York style pizza is my favorite and my boyfriend lives for the wings and stuffed pizzas! The quality of the food is great and the delivery drivers are fast and friendly! One of my favorite places in Williamsport for sure!!
My favorite pizza spot in town! Their specialty pizza are amazing, and the chicken salad is ALWAYS so fresh and delicious! Staff is always so warm and welcoming. Would give 100 stars ?
Right when we opened the door me and my mother were greeted with that wonderful aroma that only fresh ingredients provide and a warm welcome from the staff. Food was phenomenal and customer service that makes you feel at home. Don't get no better than that. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐