New Haven Style Pizza

18 N Church St, West Chester - 19380
152 reviews
Pizza
(610) 436-5814

Never do they let me down!!! I have always been pleased with anything I've ever gotten from here. No matter what you get off of the menu, it's delicious. Mrs. Bottos's soup and her coleslaw are delicious!!! They take pride in all they prepare. Just amazingly outstanding!!

This is my favorite pizza shop. Have to share a funny story. Ordered dinner for the family this evening which included a cheesesteak. Picked it up with my 12 year old and savored the wonderful smells of my favorite pizza shop. Upon arriving home my son darts from the car with the food and makes a b-line for FortniteI start to unpack the food and the cheesesteak is missing. I ask my son. Claims he hasn’t seen it. Call the shop and they graciously agree to replace though certain it had been in the bag. Drive back to my favorite pizza shop. The smells make me want more of their delicious food. Seriously the best pizza around bar none! I looked in the snow and the street where I had parked sure I’d find a “man down” soggy cheesesteak and honestly hoping I find it so I know I’m not nuts!My favorite pizza shop is again wonderful and replace the wayward cheesesteak. Can’t say enough about these guysArrive back home to my son happily engrossed in Fortnite. Deliver the new cheesesteak to my mother in law and as I walk through the living room on top of some furniture boxes is…. You guessed it the original cheesesteak! I ask my son and he has literally no idea why he put it there and has absolutely no recollection of doing soOk hat in hand moment. I never for a moment disbelieved my favorite pizza place that the original cheesesteak was in the bag to begin with but also never in a million years would have expected it to be sitting atop old furniture boxes in the living room! So I call New Haven back and share the saga which by this point is truly epic. We had a good laugh and I asked if they would allow me to pay for the 2nd cheesesteak. With a smile you can hear through the phone and a chuckle I was told not to worry about it.Seriously folks. You HAVE to try New Haven pizza. The absolutely BEST pizza in West Chester and some of the nicest, kindest people making it tick. Thank you for your kindness to an extremely confused man in a Hawaiian shirt on a Tuesday night. : )

I have been coming here for years; it is always the same very good pizza and chease fries. Service is fast and friendly

Great menu with a big variety of choices. Awesome Margherita ? pizza! ?

If you're a fan of the blackened crust that seems to be a trend ruling out a lot of pizza joints for people like me who don't like the taste of charcoal, this is not the place for you.If you like pizza crust that's light, slightly crispy, and unbrowned, then give New Haven's a try.If you're a fan of thin-crust New York style pizza, as am I, you might be disappointed. New Haven's crust is thicker, and but not Sicilian thick. However, if you can like more than one style of pizza, you might find you can happily add New Haven's pizza to your list of favorites.

Words can't describe the wonderful work you did on my trading account, I am delighted I trusted you and give you a chance to help grow my $1000 into $12,000 in just a week, Mrs Amandra Kelly my family and I are forever indebted to you for the financial stability you brought to our home, I advice the entire public to invest with Amandra Kelly, contact via WhatsApp: +14694540374 Email: [email protected]

Good pizza here. You can also pick desserts from the cooler also.

What can I say.....the place is amazing, food is delicious, and the family are the most kind, hardworking people I know.

Amazing.. I lived in west Chester for a long time growing up. I moved to Virginia 2011. Every-time I’m in the west Chester I go there first stop. When I leave I take it back with me, just got a order in Thursday. Delivery from pa to Va ( my delivery driver) amazing ever time! Thank You New Havens

Definitely has reached into my top places if I’m in the area again!