*10 STARS WORTHY!!* Best customer service. Best fresh dough (homemade??). Best (hand-cut?) fries. Reasonably priced. Stayed at a hotel in the area and found this hidden gem! Best "mom and pop" pizza shop. I was only in town for 3 days and ate here twice! Best fries and stromboli! Now I am back home, an hour and a half away, and I am highly tempted to make the drive because it was that amazing! (No dine-in due to COVID). Calling ahead is highly suggested.
The lady inside the restaurant is really super polite and also treat customers as their own family! Honestly their pizza is amazing, their pizza is #1 in state college in my opinion! I would definitely recommend trying their cheese pizza!! They are my #1 spot for a real authentic pizza spot!
I love the food and nice staff. Delicious menu and quick service. Very fair prices and right-size portions.
Best pizza I’ve had in state college by far. Only rival is faccia luna but I prefer this place.
I grew up on New Jersey pizza, and I thought I'd never find a non-NJ restaurant that could capture that unique, delicious taste. Luckily, my family and I discovered Margarita's!! If you like your pizza tasty, no-nonsense, and prepared and served by two of the nicest people in town, I encourage you to give Margarita's a try. Easily the best pizza we've found in State College.
Love the pizza! Me and my friends go there every week to eat there when we meet up.
Best pizza at state. 8.5I ordered about 25 minutes before closing. The pizzas were not consistent. One of the pizzas was practically burnt on the bottom and the other was undercooked. Still really good pizzas and we enjoyed both a lot. The sauce is some of my favorite that I’ve ever had. And the cheese was really good too.
Delicious food, very reasonable prices... and the hosts are amazing people. I kid you not: when you visit, you are family... and you are treated that way. Make sure you check their specials board - you won't go wrong. Or go for my favorite: the personal calzone. Or the sausage parm. Or the meatball sub. Or... Ok let's face it. No matter what you get, it will be made in front of you and taste out of this world. Margarita's is one of those little "local places" that you gotta check out.
Pizza was great.....the sweet lady even brought it out to my car best Connolly in town too!!!!!Can't wait to go back!
The absolute best pizza in State College.