New York Super Subs

1827 Murray Ave, Pittsburgh - 15217
104 reviews
Sandwich Shop American
(412) 586-7057

Huge, delicious hoagies! The bread is fantastic and the service is super friendly. The homemade cannolis are great too.

Went to the Squirrel Hill location and got the meatball hoagie, it was absolutely terrible. Meatballs had the consistency of a paste. Will not be returning

Extremely unimpressed. The meatballs tasted like chef boyardee and needed seasoning badly. The cheesesteak sub was good quality steak but had almost no onions and peppers and rather dry especially because the cheese was melted on the bread instead of the steak. Definitely not going back.

I really wanted to like the food since I had read so many good reviews but I was disappointed. I asked the young woman what she would recommend- one of the subs or one of the sandwiches and she suggested the pastrami sandwich. Yes, it was a huge sandwich filled with lots of meat but the meat was so fatty that it was not at all pleasant to eat and I ended up throwing away most of the sandwich.Maybe I'll try again or maybe I won't.

Look this place was bomb! ? we tried the chicken cheesesteak, hot Italian, regular cheesesteak, 2 different kinds of meatballs and their potato salad. And I seriously can’t say one bad thing. Everything was so good. Reasonable prices for the amount of food you get. Staff was friendly. Definitely will be back. I want a corned beef!

Really good steak and cheese hoagie. You can tell quality meat is being used. The people there were really nice. No doubt I will go there again.

Look this place was bomb! ? we tried the chicken cheesesteak, hot Italian, regular cheesesteak, 2 different kinds of meatballs and their potato salad. And I seriously can’t say one bad thing. Everything was so good. Reasonable prices for the amount of food you get. Staff was friendly. Definitely will be back. I want a corned beef!

Had a bomb Italian sub! You can literally smell the Fresh ingredients walking thru the door! You also get the option of two sides with a sub which is awesome! I got 2 sides of pickles (I’m obsessed). The second we walked in Daphne greeted us with a smile and was so sweet. Love this place! I’ll definitely be back.

Ordered the cheesesteak. This place is legit! Tender seasoned meat, veggies cooked through, especially the onions (so important)!! This place also has remarkable bread which it’s competitors in the area seem to not consider important ! Crisp baguette type bread with a nice crunch and soft inside. Customer service is friendly, which is another thing it’s competitors don’t seem to consider important!

Ordered subs and sides for tailgating and Clint took very good care of us! He packed everything up for us nice and neat. Thanks!