I live out of town and have been craving Pagley’s, so tonight I bought dinner for my family. I was SO disappointed in the quality of food that I honestly will never order here again. My fettuccini alfredo was bland, the chicken was hard and dry, and the salad was completely inedible. My salad was brown and my sister found black pieces of lettuce in hers. This meal was definitely not worth the $70 I spent. My mom liked her raviolis, which is the only reason I’m giving it 2 stars.
Get some help for the take out people!!!Or just a thought have all take out go thru the patio outside...I was on hold for 33 minutes. Drove up placed my order and then waited....and waited...and waited as the hostess had to seat, do check out and take out and cover the phone...jeezThank goodness the food is wonderful.
Best ravioli ever! Red sauce is the best too!! Hubby had pizza delicious also. Service was excellent fast, and friendly. This is our second time here from Ohio. Can’t wait to come back.
One of the worst restaurants I have ever been too. I'm giving it 2 stars as the service was great. The food though was atrocious. The meatball was grainy and tasted funny and the ravoli and sauce tasted like it came from a can. I have no idea how this place is as famous as it is.
Fantastic meal as always!
Always good Italian food. The ribeye is always perfect and every type of pasta is great as well. Always enjoy going there. Staff is really friendly as well.
Recently made my first time visit to Pagley's Pasta & More. I will be going back to try some of the other menu selections. It is not elegant, but I was not looking for that. We were greeted quickly, seated quickly, and served without any delay. The food was very tasty and the staff was friendly.
Were new to the neighborhood, food was great, portions large good value for the money. Attentive and responsive staff
Angel hair with house red sauce was good. I usually get the Sicilian pasta which is to die for. Server was wonderful and there were a bunch of us, she did great.
Really nice experience! We were a party of ten Italians and the waitress even though the only one in the building handling the parties and bar and cashier and take out orders was nice to us. We weren’t rushed and timing of food was perfect. All the orders right. Not loud environment. And of course the food was just great. Hot sausage and pepper oil and garlic spaghetti. Pasta Fagliou. Mangia.