Mangino’s Pizzeria

2710 Wilmington Rd, New Castle - 16105
112 reviews
Pizza Italian Comfort Food
(724) 202-6689

It's a nice place first time I was there. Food was excellent and the service was too. The waitress was very patient with our big crowd and those of us that came late.

Im halfway through my meal and im writing this review should tell you how good the food is. Fast prompt service and excellent food.

I had the pepperoni puff and wedding soup it was really good!

I took my dad and son here for my dad's birthday lunch. We all had pepperoni puffs, wedding soup and a drink for $8.99. A lot of food for the price. It was really good too. They give you a tea spoon for your soup. Why?! Lol

Wonderful, unique pizza and tasty salads. I loved the spinach and tomato pizza. The restaurant was clean and the staff was friendly!

First time there and we'll definitely be back. I had the cheese ravioli, and it was delicious! I cant wait to try more....

DON’T COME BACK AND WE DON’T WANT YOUR BUSINESS is what the owner told me after posting a negative review about a food order I picked up for my parents. My mom called them and told them the pizza she ordered wasn’t correct. They never offered to make it right. So when she ordered another pizza (at a later date) and I went to pick it up the owner made me pay for the pizza first then confronted me about the negative review I posted. When I told him yes it was me that posted the negative review that’s when he told me DON’T COME BACK AND WE DON’T WANT YOUR BUSINESS. Just wanted to let the community know and I didn’t think it was fair.

Amazing food!! Great atmosphere

This is my favorite pizza shop in the New Castle PA area. I've tried just about every pizza shop in the New Castle area and I keep coming back to Mangino's. My wife likes their meatball dugout but we both like their side salads. pepperoni rolls, and cheese pizza. One thing the Neshannock location needs to improve on is wait time. If they tell 45mins guaranteed you can add another 15-20 minutes onto your wait time.

Very clean and inviting. The meatball dugout was excellent. Loaded with huge meatballs cheese and sauce. The pepperoni roll was ok. We're definitely going back