II Tomato

2409 Wilmington Rd, New Castle - 16105
167 reviews
Italian Pizza Burgers
(724) 658-3380

Had the chicken marsala. It was excellent! My wife and i both enjoyed our meal and great service.

Enjoyed our first visit. Friendly staff, delicious appetizer and dessert, and Buffalo trace in stock!

Had a party with my coworkers. It was a great time. The food was good and the staff were very friendly.

Great place to meet with friends. Atmosphere and food were great. Menu has just enough on it for everyone!

First time going and waited 1 hour and 45 minutes for food. I wanted to go in back and just fix my.own food. Then it comes out and it's luke warm. Waitress,Heather, forgot our drink orders a couple times. Just not a good first impression.

We held our Volleyball banquet here for our Neshannock girls. The food was fantastic and atmosphere was wonderful. Thank you for a great afternoon!! ?

The sauce, greens and appetizer were EXCELLENT! And the meatballs, perfect! $6.50 for a draft beer was a bit inappropriate considering the meals are fairly priced. The two gals working, and keep in mind we were one of 3 tables of 2 diners could and would VANISH for extended periods. Very extended. They were both extremely polite however and that was nice. I just dont appreciate waiting to get my card back after paying 10 minutes later. Will be back for sure tho. Im sure the help will turn over.

I loved this place and have been going there for years. Last night at the bar was the most angry and disgusted bartender I ever encountered. Not only angry but when my friend and I had our beers refreshed she refilled the SAME glasses and we had no idea if we got back our own glass. When we asked her about it she said don't worry I did not mix them up, REALLY!. Working for tips I don't think so, left without ordering and will not return until she is gone.

Two Tomatoes offers a great ambiance but do not care about their customers. We had our wedding rehearsal dinner here, we reserved the room over two months in advance and picked our meal with set prices prior to the event. Two days before the event, the owner calls us and says the price of meat has gone up and we have to pay the difference even though prices were already set. They also told us we could not change our mind about the menu because they already bought the meat for our buffet, regardless of the price change. Additionally, they would not cooperate with us, they seem nice and concerning about food allergies and dietary restrictions on the phone, but when can down to the meal they didn't do anything and people in our party could not eat because of it, and we still had to pay for them... Continuing they skipped an entire course of our meal and argued with us when said we didn't receive it, all food came out lukewarm or cold. The buffet was family style and they said we could have as much as we want of a certain dish but when asked, they said they couldn't give us more. Then to top it all off it was karaoke night, and we endure that our entire dinner even though we were in a "private room". Please do not go here, it is not worth your time unless it's the last option, the owner even told us he could not help us in any way when we were very disappointed because by putting the customer-first he would have to close his doors.

Two Tomatoes offers a great ambiance but do not care about their customers. We had our wedding rehearsal dinner here, we reserved the room over two months in advance and picked our meal with set prices prior to the event. Two days before the event, the owner calls us and says the price of meat has gone up and we have to pay the difference even though prices were already set. They also told us we could not change our mind about the menu because they already bought the meat for our buffet, regardless of the price change. Additionally, they would not cooperate with us, they seem nice and concerning about food allergies and dietary restrictions on the phone, but when can down to the meal they didn't do anything and people in our party could not eat because of it, and we still had to pay for them... Continuing they skipped an entire course of our meal and argued with us when said we didn't receive it, all food came out lukewarm or cold. The buffet was family style and they said we could have as much as we want of a certain dish but when asked, they said they couldn't give us more. Then to top it all off it was karaoke night, and we endure that our entire dinner even though we were in a "private room". Please do not go here, it is not worth your time unless it's the last option, the owner even told us he could not help us in any way when we were very disappointed because by putting the customer-first he would have to close his doors.