I got an Italian sub from them their cheese was so thin you could almost see through it and they only put two slices. The hard salami was so thin and as far as pepperonis they put four little tiny pepperonis on an Italian sub. That’s utterly ridiculous. Considering they charge you what they charge you. I will never order another sub from them ever again. I’ve had problems in the past with their chicken wings still having feathers on them. If you want good food do not come here. Save your time and save your money. Pizzas not so bad. And the people there are nice. Just the food sucks. And I did not put a picture up because I was so angry I bunch of the sandwich into a ball n tossed it. It wasn’t worth eating.
2 slices and a soda for $5The guys were very nice and outgoing! The pizza was good, I’ll be back for more!
I love sluggers I just wish they'd open the dining room back up...
Great experience and a delicious pizza. Love that thin crust!
I've gone to this establishment and enjoy the dining area. The owner is so cool Mr C. They'd jus opened the dining room for dining inside. Service and food is GREAT!!
Favorite pizza in Lancaster. Easily. Never eaten inside. Only ordered pickup or delivery (many times over the years) and never once had an issue. Good pricing, quick and consistent.
Pizza arrived very quick, but was warm/room temperature at best as if they just warmed it up rather than bake the whole pie fresh. There was almost no tomato sauce, and the sauce that was there did not have a good taste. Mushrooms had a bad taste, as if they were from a can that went bad .Crust was decent.
I moved away for almost two years and the first time I ordered from Sluggers again, they knew who I was and asked about my kids. If this isn't the perfect example of community oriented, what is? Their pizza is always good- they're always busy.. which is a good sign ANDDD.. you can get delivery WITHOUT door dash lol.Check it out. You'll be happy.
Fantastic pizza! And really cheap. I love this place! They make good salads too but I mean it’s a pizzeria.
Pizza is good (quality varies depending on who's working!)...Cheeseburger sub was one of the worst I've ever had! Won't go back for anything but pizza! (in their favor they are pleasant and efficient)