You just can't go wrong here! The seafood choices are always good quality. They process on the premises and fillet as needed, keeping it on ice. They specialize in crabs and their prep items are done on the premises as wellAll is fresh and delicious!!There is also a cafe on the premises and you just can't get it any fresher than that!! Please stop in and give them a try or ask around.
Best crab sandwich I've had, kind of pricey for a sandwich/burger, but it is worth every darn cent.
Wow, 1st time here n so so good. Little bit pricey but that's seafood. Make sure to double check hours before going in. Nice little outside seating area...plus u can BYOB
The seafood here is magnificent enough to make grown men cry! The Cafe has incredible chef prepared dishes. Not local? They ship!!!
My mouth is watering now jus thinking of the Cordon Blue oyster Po'boy Or the Soft shell crab & crabcake sandwich. Mr Bill himself is always there present, welcoming and thank all his quest/patrons for coming in.. Always a cordial atmosphere. Love going and always leave with good thoughts of my Mr. Bill's experince.. Thank you!
Ehh Mr bills has always had great seafood but now with the restaurant the flavors are missing. We've been here a few times, each time trying something new and it all just taste bland/plain. I.e. spending a good amount on the lobster roll that honestly taste like nothing, honestly it's not worth it unless you're buying their crabs.
Best place in Lancaster for fresh sea food. The staff is very helpful with selections.
We had a wonderful meal. The help was very nice and attentive. I didn't realize it was BYOB. But still had a great time will go back for sure
Outstanding seafood store plus cafe! We live in SF (sadly we don't get this much diversity of seafood where we live) and religiously visit this place when we are in town visiting in-laws. The staff would jokingly ask us when we are planning to move to Lancaster every time we stop by LOL. We don't get east coast oysters and other east coast fish such as grouper, black bass and boston blue so we make sure to purchase those. Everything is fresh. But the highlight of this place is the Fat Crab Sandwich! Amazing soft-shell crab + crab cake = decadence. This is what keeps us returning to the place! This place is not cheap - yet it doesn't stop us going - but we would be broke if we moved to Lancaster! Staff is knowledgeable and really friendly along with the proprietor who welcomes us when we are in town. We can't wait to visit again!
Stopped in for lunch and was served a delicious crab cake sandwich. Fantastic. Best softshell crab I've had as well.You're right in the market when dining at the cafe, so be prepared for that (oysters on ice nearby, etc) but it's a cafe in a seafood market, you wouldn't be here if you didn't like fish.