The Upper Crust

19 York St, Gettysburg - 17325
269 reviews
Pizza American
(717) 549-2444

The Czech Pierogi and Pulled Pork pizza were phenomenal. The atmosphere and staff were great, true reflection of the owners in providing a great experience. The seating along the sidewalk inside the restaurant afforded you the best of both in and outside dining. Our server Alina was equally as great as the establishment. Will definitely recommend and return whenever in Gettysburg. Sorry about the partially eaten food pic, I realized I must commend you all after I began eating. ?

The look of the restaurant is nice, it is what drew us in. However, we were quickly disappointed. We ordered app, macaroni and cheese pretzels that were about $12 and we only got three, we are a family of 4, so we had to creatively split the pretzels so we could all have some. Second, we wanted a half red and half white pie, and that could not be done. Understandable the logistics just wouldn’t work. However, we wanted a white pizza with half spinach and half pepperoni. We were told we could not do that either. For $18 we should have been able to, but upon getting the pizza and seeing how small it was, it wouldn’t have been ideal for our family. And we asked for a Virgin drink and were denied that as well. It was very underwhelming when we could have taken the money to one of the other pizza places in town and got at the very least got half spinach and half pepperoni.

Great location, very friendly staff, was seated right away. Nice menu, good selection. We were on a road trip so no alcoholic drinks for us but the selection seemed decent. The food was delicious and we didn’t leave a crumb! Pricing was fair. There were games in the back, if we come back to Gettysburg we’ll definitely return! Also, we were told the the gift shop “Gallery 30” across the street is theirs also and it is a MUST!!

Staff is kind and helpful. Nice place to unwind and relax on a warm summer Saturday evening with the windows open giving an feeling of being outdoors while being indoors, which is a unique touch that let's sunlight in and creates a unique atmosphere. Levi, our waiter was attentive. The gentleman who initially assisted was helpful in answering several questions with a cheerful attitude. Our Margherita pizza had a nice flavor, but wasn't what we were expecting, as the usual Margherita pizza has melted medallions of mozzarella. It's neat to see your pizza dough being formed and cooking in the fire oven! We enjoyed our drinks and will return to try other menu items.

The pictures of the food looked good, however at 8pm the kitchen was closed. The sign on the door said the kitchen was open until 10pm. Maybe they should change the sign ?‍♀️

The food and service was excellent. Lots of vegetarian options. The waitress very kindly bought out a large bowl of water for our pup too.

Service was extremely fast. So many amazing pizza topping combination choices. Very delicious and had more than enough to take home for a second meal.

Great place for any size group. Nice weather..they open the entire front wall to the outdoors. Huge brick ovens. Pizza takes just minutes. Skee ball and other games to play before or after eating. Great friendly staff!

First off I'm not a big pizza eater but this place is great. Grandkids got pepperoni and my wife and I got the Gumbo pizza. It was fantastic the andouille sausage was nice and spicy and the shrimp was very good too. It doesn't sound like it would work but it's great. Also had the pierogies and they were huge. The waitress was great. They also have skee ball and other games for the kids in the back us they are free. Recommend if you are in town.

To start off, the place looks great. It has a chill yet family friendly atmosphere with kind and attentive employees.The food was absolutely delicious and the place serves as a modern touch in the town of Gettysburg. A great refresher to the usual historic architecture.But the prices are ridiculous. I got the Hummus and Labneh Duo which was $11. Super high quality food but at most should be like $8. Along with a Pepperoni pizza for $17. Granted, delicious high quality pizza, but could at most feed 2 people. I’ve been to places for the same quality and size where the pie was $8. To finish off I had the $10 Cocoa Brownie which had a creamy rich vanilla ice cream on top of a decent brownie. This one could barely feed 2 people, granted it’s a dessert.A high quality place but with way too high prices. Come if you have a special occasion or date.