Pizza House

71 W Lincoln Ave, Gettysburg - 17325
119 reviews
Pizza
(717) 334-1308

I really don't want to even give 1 star but I did. I appreciate that the one and only employee working was working, however the pizzas were small and The sub I got was terrible, it only had one slice of ham literally and the bread was burnt! I will not be returning but the 2 pizzas and sub I got was not 40 dollars worth at all! I get inflation and all but I try to support our local restaurants and they failed me this time ? I was told 20-25 minutes and waited 20 more on top of that, but that didn't even bother me.

Really good subs and the absolute best wings. If the guy answering the phone isn't stoned its easy to order.

Their food is delicious, but their hours are extremely inconsistent and there’s no way to tell that they’re closed until you show up. They don’t update their answering machine or their FB page if they’re closed outside of their posted hours.

Great pizza! And great staff

Pizza had nice thin crust. Not greasy at all. The gentleman was so sweet. Only draw back was the bathroom. But ill be back to eat there.

Shout out to Jeremy and chris and Linda my favorite pizza gurus!! Also Mary and John!! All who have been a part of my life since I was very young child!!! Your pizza and your dedication to the recipe and keeping it 100% always has been apart of my life for the last 35 years and longer for my fathers who introduced us to the best pizza ever made!.!.!! Keep it up and much love from us!!.!. Every pizza is a peice af art and we love you all!! Jeremy thankYou for keeping this icon alive!!! See you soon

Things have changed and not for the better, I have always been a big fan of pizza house and frequently will chose pizza house over Tommy’s. Not anymore. Their crust is 2/3 the size that it was just a couple of months ago, it was also weirdly symmetrical. A homemade pizza is never perfectly round. The crust felt, tasted and looked frozen which is something I have never encountered anywhere before.(it looked mass produced). Not saying it is, just my experience. Not only is quality declining and taste taking a beating they also had the audacity to up their prices, a large pepperoni pizza has always been just over $11 now they charge 14.30, the same cost as Tommy’s. Greed will kill this place.

Chris makes one of th best strombolis I've ever had!!! He is a god among men. I will come here every time I'm in the area.

This pizza shop is a really good pizza place to eat,old fashioned pizza,talk to the owner he is been there since 70's,same pizza style..loved the place,very good customer service,thanks pizza house..hope to comeback soon..

Made quick, good service, did not solicit tip on a take-out .. delicious pizza, great crust. What more ya want?