McGarrey's Oakwood Cafe

1624 W 38th St, Erie - 16508
376 reviews
Family American
(814) 866-0552

very good food and friendly staff

Reubens are excellent, also love chicken and biscuits!

We were in Erie for several days and ate here twice. The Service was friendly. The Menu was extensive. The Food was Wonderful.

This was my 1st time dining at this restaurant. I have always heard good things so I tried it out... the food was delicious great flavor and when my meal was brought out the food was nice and steamy hot. Staff was also very pleasant and kept checking on us too refill our drinks or see if we wanted dessert. There was no way I could get dessert after the portion from my meal. If you're looking for a nice sit down restaurant too bring the family this is your place. Fast and friendly service good food hearty portion and reasonably priced. I definitely will be a returning customer in the near future.

This is a great place for families and good food. Bless the server for putting up with my extremely hangry grandson. I like how the children's cheeseburgers came as two sliders into of one big burger we would need to cut. It's a clean, contemporary look inside. My daughter enjoyed the parmesan topped haddock, and I liked the hot turkey sandwich.

I really want to like this place the waiters and waitress really seem hard-working, and just in general the wait staff really do what they can to make you feel comfortable at home. The restaurant is beautifully decorated and clean I really want to go back, but just something about when I got my food was not delicious at all.The pasta was dry that you can tell it was sitting around for a while.Some of the chicken I ordered the entire thing tasted like old oil!Our appetizers was warm on the outside and cold on the inside.I really really want to like this place for the customer service part is absolutely amazing but there's something about the food itself wasn't quite to par

It was a great restaurant! Our waitress was very kind and helpful I had the spaghetti and French fries highly recommend

The very best Reuben sandwiches in Erie, hands down. Also lots and lots of other delicious foods to eat as well. They always have treated me good and with hardly any wait no matter how busy they are. Nice, Clean, Cheerful place to come for a sandwich, or sit down dinner, or a couple drinks. An Excellent place to go. 5 stars and 2 thumbs up!!

If want a filling, tasty meal that is made fresh, this is a must. Everything on the menu is good. You get a great and filling portion for the price. We choose take out over dine in, as we don't want to wait and dine in. Always a line and wait which means its a popular place with great food.

We always get carry out and they can never get the order right! They charge for all the extras and that’s fine, but they never put them in the bag or on the food ! So frustrating! No more business for them! Especially when the cook argues that your order was made right!