Bay House Oyster Bar & Restaurant

6 Sassafras Pier, Erie - 16507
80 reviews
Seafood
(814) 413-7440

A wonderful evening with friends. Great food and drink with a quiet atmosphere.

Everything from the food to service was phenomenal. Crab cakes, mussels, lobster tail and steak were all cooked perfectly and delicious. Would gladly dine there again.

Great food, view, staff. First visit and can’t wait to come back. $99 for the seafood tower is a steal. Three of us ate off of it.

The staff and food was exceptional. The temperature in the restaurant was extremely cold. Make note to request section 300 where there are no ceiling fans above if you don’t like it so cold.

I knocked a star off only because it was so warm inside, but otherwise me enjoyed our seafood towers, as we have in the past. Best place to curb your desire for raw shellfish.

This is a wonderful place to eat. Great food, excellent service and beautiful sunsets!

Wonderful experience, great oysters!

We were enjoying an overnight stay at the Bayfront Sheraton and wanted to have a special dinner (especially oysters) at the Bay House. The cocktails were perfect and we sampled 2 dozen oysters, including 6 different varieties from multiple regions of North America (and even New Zealand). The oysters were all fresh, delicious, and beautifully presented with several delectable sauces. We also enjoyed one appetizer (mushroom ravioli with short rib) and one entree special (chili-rubbed duck breast with creamy polenta) between the two of us. The service was impeccable and we can’t wait to visit again next month.

Oysters were great! Food tasted like it came straight out of a bag.

Great food in a beautiful location. We definitely recommend it here.