The cask pale ale which is brewed on site was a great beer! The fish and chips was also excellent. We arrived at the same time as a tour bus group which filled the pub. After a short wait while the staff got everyone's orders, the drinks and food arrived quickly. Excellent service and ability to adjust to unexpected customers.
I really enjoyed this bar. Bartender (curly haired fella) was engaging while simultaneously taking care of business. Never wanted for a drink or had to stare him down awkwardly to put an order in... he was on top of it... and with a witty remark to boot. Drinks (Peach Kentucky Mules) were tasty af and the food (pretzels with beer cheese and beef and Guinness) was delicious. Best place I've been to in a long time. Obviously a great team in place.
My group of friends and I went here to celebrate a birthday. It was my first time there and I got the fried chicken sandwich. Let’s just say, I needed to go back for another one (which I did for my one year wedding anniversary)! The beverages, the staff, the atmosphere and the food was great and I will definitely go back!! Great place to eat while in Carlisle!
Excellent service and delicious food. Top 5 shepherd’s pie ever!
One of my all-time favorite restaurants have been coming here since the mid-90s in fact my name's on a wall in the back for finishing 98 beers and 98 in 99 beers in 99.A really wonderful beer selection of real beers not as fancy hipster stuff. Thi k engliah ales German Wheats. Plus they have a great food selection is always cooked fresh to order and friendly staff
Get your passport and get going!
It was our first time! Met friends for drinks and dinner and had a great time. Our server was wonderful and the food was delicious. Great selection of beer! Would totally return.
Loved this place in the past, this time however not so much. No gravy at 6pm, dropped our crab dip so it was served with the meal, chicken pot pie had very little chicken in it at all. The crab dip was very small, ok I get it, however it was literally 50% raw onions, which was not listed on the menu. Ver very disappointed.
Stayed in Carlisle for a night on the road at the end of a road trip. Had a great server, Danielle, and the food was terrific- onion rings, steak sub, and pulled pork mac and cheese. The only disappointment was that the bartender was not very knowledgeable about the beers on tap, which was unusual for a pub!
MCP is a beer lovers paradise. Multiple house drafts and dozens of other choices in cans and bottles. The menu is full of alcohol absorbing pub favorites. I chose the fried cheese curds which were lightly fried and good and the special burger (a mix of different meets including Waygu) the fries were perfectly cooked and the burger tasty but smallish and overwhelmed by the bun- perhaps not a $17 burger but a really good $12 burger. The place was lively but service, even at the bar, a touch slow- bartender really didn’t liven up until the end. This seems a place to go with the boys/girls/team but maybe not a romantic or family dinner. We’ll come again but won’t rush