Hamilton Restaurant

55 W High St, Carlisle - 17013
360 reviews
Hot Dogs American
(717) 249-4410

Cash only, but great prices for good meals. Not fancy, but plenty of good food. Ordered a ribeye steak sandwich platter and was more than I could eat. Breakfasts look great, my wife loves the hot dogs

Great food and service. Been going to the Hamilton for years with my family. Love the hatchi dogs and Greek salad. Shakes are heavenly. Nice traditional family restaurant.

I went here for the first time ever and I was not disappointed. The food was incredible and the staff were very inviting and made you feel at home. I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a quick and delicious meal. It's cash only so be sure to have some with if you don't they do have an ATM in the restaurant.

This restaurant is know for their Hot-Cee Hot Dogs with Chili, cheese & onion . Also the plate of fries we excellent. We understand how they have been in business all these years, the dogs were delicious. The service was excellent. Both services make this place a go to place to eat.

Great place to eat. Food taste is really good

Id go with a good rating if they had one but I can’t do very good- it actually could be very good if you manage your expectations- a good, old fashioned, fill you up diner. I probably should have tried a basic burger and I probably should have ordered the steak sandwich more than medium or with cheese. Great fries and gravy. Salads are big and fresh but basic. The price is right. Service is “Jersey diner” style but they get the job done. Not bad for a greasy spoon

Probably closer to 4 1/2 stars. Food is always consistent and nice size portions. Menu doesn't change as most of the daily "specials" are the same each day, or so it seems. Salads are huge as are breakfast combos. Steak sandwich is a slice of ribeye steak that extends about 4" out from either side of the roll. We usually look for Lisa as our waitress as she is super nice and very attentive. Interesting dynamic between the servers and the kitchen, part of the show! Would not hesitate ordering breakfast, a dinner or a sandwich. Not the biggest fan, though, of their hot dogs, just doesn't have the same taste as other places but probably their most popular item. Might be the only thing on the menu that I would not order on a regular basis but might once in a while.

No particular reason we picked this as our choice for dinner, but what an awesome family ran establishment. We had never been here but the entire staff and owner Mr. Thomas made the three of us feel as though we were a part of his family. Food was awesome and everyone seemed to know the entire family and enjoy themselves. Definitely will be back. Wish them all many more years of success. Will light that candle Thomas, thank you for dinner and safe travels to your beautiful Greece.

Nine people sat down and got waited on for breakfast and kept on moving very fast and everything was totally awesome. Very glad we stopped. The food was great

We stopped in here on our way back to Virginia. The food was so good, and the service was excellent. I would recommend anyone passing through to stop by and eat.