Mill Creek Pizza

1091 Mill Creek Rd, Allentown - 18106
125 reviews
Italian American Pizza
(610) 530-7366

Amazing staff. Great food. Will be coming here again

I haven’t met a more rude staff. The feeling of being unwelcome came right when I opened the door. If you want to feel like garbage while you eat then this is the place. Even more so since the food is so bad it will make you feel like actually trash. Never coming here again.

I was really looking forward to this place, but never have I received worse service. The manager was rude and makes people feel stupid and unwelcome. I was shocked. And the pizza wasn’t that great either, heard someone complain about sanitary issues. Never again.

SEE EDIT BELOW: from five star to one star.Macungie and the surrounding area suffer from pizza mediocrity. As a Philadelphia native I guess I will never find what I am used to. Crust should crunch like a potato chip. Not eat like white bread. This is not 5 star pizza. But for the area’s pizza it is one of the better ones. Service is friendly, priced very good. EDIT: This facility now has a $10 minimum for cards. Was not posted on the door or at the register. Was informed only after I ordered my lunch. I am not a pizza shop owner so I may be wrong, but I believe this will alienate an entire lunch crowd. I understand cost have went up, but to steal money from me is not acceptable. Joe’s Pizza down the street, is mediocre, but they don’t steal my money. Put my .99 cents to good work, I will not be returning.

We ordered subway from this location.My husbands tuna fish was great.However I ordered all american sub,all together our bill was 20 something my sandwich was 10.99.However when opened my snadwich had very small amout lettuce,about 3 inches ham rest of sandwich empty.I was so mad.We ordered by the internet-never order this way fom Walmart subway.I know we will never order from subway again. very poor,this is the 1st time I ever posted my review of any thing.

Mill Creek Pizza is just a great pizza joint for takeout, or as we often do a quick bite dining in. Their pizza is a thicker bread-ier crust with a nice sauce and a good helping of cheese. Salads are always good, and it seems as if they have beer on tap as well. The wait staff was terrific. They also have great subs and garlic knots you should try.

I went into this place to get something to take out. I ordered a 8inch cheesesteak. I thought it was 8.99 when I payed my bill it was 11.58 . I needed to eat something because I’m diabetic and it was quick. When I got home to eat it it had hardly any meat on it. I kid you not. It had about a tablespoon of meat on it. It had so much lettuce on it. They were so stingy with the meat. For 11.58 was not worth it at all. Someone there needs to train on how to make a cheesesteak that’s going to be worth the money they are charging people. It’s a rip off. I will never ever go to this place again

I'm not one to complain, but wow this place is absolutely terrible. The stuffed pepper looks like they microwaved it and then straight to the to go container. The service and hospitality are below average. Save your money and go else where. Be better guys. No way does this look anything like the picture on your menu of stuffed peppers. Ridiculous.

As far as the pizza....total trash. No sauce on their slices and you can taste that the cheese is low end. The fact that some of you rated it so highly just confirms that the people of Lehigh Valley don't know jacksh*t about good pizza. I'll never return.

Delicious! Fantastic fast service and amazing food. The quantity is worth the cost. There is so much meat on the buffalo chicken cheese steak your going to need a spoon. I really like how the crust on the calzone is on the thinner side can't compare. You got a good thing going good job everyone.