Really great pizza. Nice atmosphere in the restaurant. Ticket times are long but that speaks more to the quality of the pizza than anything. My only complaint is that the smallest table I'd for like 6-8 people. As a party of 2, I felt awkward taking up such a large table.
Had a large party over on a Friday night to help with a move. Wanted to order ahead so pizza would be ready when we got there. Called more than once to a busy signal. Finally headed to the restaurant and decided to order and just wait for our food. Abby's pizza is worth the wait. Got there and were immediately turned away. Told unless we had called ahead, (we had multiple times to no avail!) we could not be served because they were 1.5 hours backed up on orders and were therefore closing early. Our biggest frustration was that there was no message on the phone and that we weren't given an option to wait. A busy pizza restaurant should have a wait to place a call on hold and have a message in the meantime. Were super disappointed with how our potential business was handled with dismissal. Especially since we were repeat customers.
I think my pizza was recycled from old pieces?? The edges don't match up... The pizza had little to no sauce and EVERY topping costs 2$ extra. 26$ for this?EDIT: I sent an email to your customer service team and never heard back. No I didn't call the manager, I don't want to argue with someone who could be involved.
This used to be the best pizza in town but something happened to their crust. It's not as crisp and kind of soft in the center. So sad, it used to be the one place I could always count on in Newberg. When they switched ownership something changed dramatically with the crust ingredients. Pizza is okay, salads are good.
This used to be my favorite pizza place. Today my daughter and I got what I swear is recycled pizza! Not only does the crust not match up, the cut marks don't line up at all! I'm absolutely shocked and disgusted! I can't believe you guys would do this! I will NEVER come here again!
Very good for parties. Abby's always has great pizza!
Steak pizza is the best. It is really delicious with green and red peppers. The chicken wings are great too, BBQ and plain are delicious. The pizza was so huge that the four of us didn't finish it.??
I love Abby's Pizza! I have been eating here for 40+ years!
I remember when this was the best place in town to get pizza. Three out of four of the last pizzas I ordered were undercooked, gooey in the middle and inedible. Tonight was charged extra for a deep dish but they just put a normal crust in a deep pan and had the edge of the pizza at an angle. See attached photos. Also, the dough is frozen, I can see the seam on it from the plastic. Sad, I would tell everyone about this place. No more.
This was my first time trying Abby's pizza. I ordered carry out so I cannot speak for the restaurant experience in itself. I can say the pizza was underwhelming. I ordered a pepperoni and it came with an over whelming amount of them. Some double and triple stacked on top of one another. Pizza I'd about a good balance of dough, cheese and toppings. This was not that. The dough did not taste fresh. It had the same consistancy as a frozen pizza. To call this pizza "Legendary " is a stretch of the imagination