Let me start with this, this Cibelli's makes the best pizza of all of them. However, you may or may not be able to stop by and get a slice of pizza because they, confusing, seem to "run out of slices." I was lucky today to get a few, but sitting here waiting I have watched 8 people come in and get turned away due to a lack of pizza availability. Taste and quality wise 5 stars, internal decision making is the reason for my 3 stars.PS: it's not due to short staffing, there are 4 people working. If you want pizza, call ahead and order and don't count on getting a slice for lunch and you will be fine.
Not ny at all. Dough is uncooked in center and times / Temps way off. No slices or pies out to see for take out slices ? I saw canned pizza sauce not San marzano take an hour each day and make your sauce and max the ovens forget the timer use your eyes. Idk what else to say not for me but for a quick bite for someone from here maybe 6 stars
Didn’t bother to tell us it was going to be an hour wait for our food before ordering so we had to sit in the parking lot and wait for an hour for our food.
Pizza is three things - crust, sauce and cheese. The crust here is excellent and they cheese they use is fine - the problem is the lack of seasoning in the sauce. The slice that I got was so bland that I wonder if they simply forgot to put salt in the sauce. The crust is so good it pulls the 1 star bland sauce up to a 4 star slice of pizza (just be sure to add salt to your slice).
Great, giant pizzas with a tasty crust and fresh toppings. An excellent choice for company lunches as well.
My wife and I went to find a sign on the door saying the dining room was closed for training. That was okay because we preferred to eat outside anyway. It's nice they have the pizza pans up on the wall showing the different sizes so you don't have to guess. You order at the counter and then they brought it out to us. We ordered a Combo, sausage pepperoni, veggies. Very good! The crust was very good as well, nicely cooked with a nice chew. A little pricy. We'd go back.
Pizza was ordered online to be ready at 5:45PM. Arrived at 5:35 and waited an hour. They threw my pizza in the oven once I arrived. 400 degree oven at a pizza joint…. Pizza is soggy and underdone. Pay them more to actually care please.
Very very good if you are craving pizza you should definitely go to Cibelli’s very good
Excellent pizza and cheese sticks! We ordered the 24 inch pizza with cheese sticks. The pizza is huge! It was so big that it rode in the back of the truck.
Great NY style pizza. Nice and floppy.