If you’re feeling like you need an upgrade from fast food pizza, Pickleman’s is the place to go. The pizza is a little pricey but well worth it. You can customize so much when you order online, even how much of a topping or sauce and even on just one side. I’ve also had their meatball sub and that was pretty good too. Their employees have always been nice to me.
The employees are always amazing, the food is good but honestly not worth the price. $28 for a drink, sandwich and half sandwich/salad is a bit ridiculous. I really hope they’re at least paying their employees well for those prices.
Great customer service, my girlfriend and I had dinner here last night. Split a tuna sandwich and garlic bread. I'll definitely be back.
Our first time in and literally just ate the best sandwich I’ve ever eaten in Stillwater. Staff was extremely helpful and friendly! We will definitely return!
Ordered online and picked it up, got home and it was missing sandwich. Called them and they said they would deliver, called us back and said they can’t deliver because it was a online order.
The asiago chicken sandwich was good. The broccoli cheese soup was not that great. The tomato basil amazing. Service while I was there was good. Overall would come back again to try some different food.
In all reality, the food is good but overpriced especially considering the size of the sandwiches and of the pizzas. I will say, their chocolate chip cookies are among some of the best I've had from fast food/restaurants. Definitely better than Insomnia down the street, believe it or not.
First time eating there and Injad the meatball and the other two in my party hand the chicken Chipotle. The meatball was not the worst nor the best meatball sandwich I have had. I would get something else if go back. Pickleman’s is definitely worth a try if you are on the strip in Stillwater.
This is a pregnant woman's choice place for food!They are quick with delivery and it's perfect every time I order.
Would I recommend to someone else, to eat here? Of course I would! I recommended it to my Mom a couple years back, and at 93, tried the same #8 Cafe Club that I got and truly loved it! ? I only wish you turn back time, so I could hear her smile over our favorite sandwich, once more!