Mazzio's Italian Eatery

1211 N Broadway St, Shawnee - 74801
104 reviews
Italian Pizza
(405) 598-8888

Service was decent. Pizza...well it's mazzios pizza. Not the best but not the worst. Biggest issue was the lack of cleanliness.

I have been here twice and both times my order was screwed up. The first time I ordered a small pizza with mushrooms, pineapples and pepperoni. They left off the pineapples qnd put exactly one mushroom on my pizza. The second time, I placedy order an hour and a half before pickup and received a different order entirely after sitting at the drive thru window for almost 30 minutes with a screaming baby in the back. I paid extra to have a medium pizza with all over pepperoni and pineapples but on one half mushrooms and received a half pepperoni pineapple pizza with the other half only mushrooms and then a sausage calzone instead of a jalapeno calzone. I'm done with this Mazzios. Never going back again. The one on Kickapoo is so much better!

I recieved a text for a medium pepperoni buster pizza for $5.00 each. I called at 2 p.m. and ordered 2. I was told it would be ready in 25 minutes. I arrived at 2:30 sat at the window for approximately 2-3 minutes before anyone came to window. Was told it would be a couple of minutes. 7 minutes later another person came to window after a few minutes I told her I could not wait as I had to go to work. Then a male came to window and said it would be a couple of minutes. I replied that is what you told me 10 minutes ago. Yeah I thought he had already put them in the oven I said I can't wait any longer I am going to be late for work. Well I can give you a discount...a couple of minutes he hands me my 2 pizzas and says no charge it is on us. I get to work and go to eat some and there is no pepperoni on it. So it takes 45 minutes to get the pizzas then they are not even correct. This use to be the only place I would get pizza looks like I will be going elsewhere from now on...

I've said it before and I'll say it again: pizza is pizza, and you would really have to go out of the way to mess it up. That being said, the pepperoni and cheese pizzas were exactly as you expected. Let's talk about the supreme. In what universe is a supreme pizza just meat and green peppers and how sprinkling of onions, because that's what I got. Disappointed. It was ready when they said it would be though, so I guess there's that.

Pizza was really disgusting cold and hard as a brick. We won't go back there again. Giorgio's in Shawnee is better. Next time I will drive further to get good pizza

Had dinner with my daughter just the 3 of us 1 salad plate 1 large pizza and 1 medium cheese bread and it was 45 dollars, super pricey, however great customer service, food came fairly fast and was very delicious.

They did not have regular crust. But the pizza we had was still good.

My favorite place to eat! Food always fresh and GOOD! Seminole and Tecumseh have the greatest staff. So down home abd comfortable. Prices are great too!

The pizza we had delivered was very good and the delivery person was very nice! Overall it was great!!

Salad bar and buffet selection was good and fresh. Service was very good as well.