OBSESSED with this place. I have never tasted better pies! It is quite literally one of my goals to taste every flavor on their menu, but so far, southern banana cream is my favorite. Literally thought I died and went to heaven when I had my first bite of that slice!
Really Good!!! Nice pies!! Great texture. Will try other ones. I give them 4 Stars because I only tried one... When we get other items will update the review!
Fantastic pies! I got three for Easter and everyone loved them. Key lime and drunken turtle were our favorites. Birthday cake is good, but maybe stick to a slice rather than a whole pie. Can’t wait to try more.
This is a very popular destination nestled in the Plaza district. We were not disappointed. They had over a dozen different kinds of pie, and the ones we chose we really good. The only detractor was the lack of seating, but many times you can find a bench or table on the sidewalk nearby.
As soon as I get off the plane this will be my stop before heading to Fort Sill. I will make sure I get there early, as the menu changes and you may find that pie you wanted is sold out for the day. I will tell you the Birthday Cake is so delicious, even the hubby who is not a sweet eater can't stop talking about it. The S'more pie was good tasted exactly like it would if you had done it yourself. The banana cream was not as good as I had hoped. We will definitely be back!
I am a pie connoisseur, and I live in Georgia, which is known for their pecan pies. I have to say this pecan pie is in my top three, and I have had pecan pies all over the south. Definitely try this pie. If you come on the weekdays there isn't much of a wait, on Saturday you will have to wait in line. Also, heat the pie slice for 15 seconds and it will be perfect.Update: I returned for some more pie. This time I was able to try the bird dog and the peanut butter.They are stingy with the punch card for slices. In the past two weeks I have purchased a ton of whole pies and a bunch of slices. They only gave me 6 stamps, when I have purchased way more slices than that.I also bought the turkey pot pie, but haven't baked it yet.My favorites in ranking order:#1 Pecan, #2 Banana, #3 tie between the Coconut & Bird Dog, #4 Peanut Butter but only if mixed with the banana pie, #5 French Silk
Have been here several times for single slices of pie, but was recently given a chicken pot pie and a drunken turtle pie as a gift from a friend. The pot pie was exceptional! I could eat it every day. Seriously. The drunken turtle was good, but really missing salt, so I fixed that by sprinkling some flaked salt I had on hand. Very good otherwise. I highly recommend trying out Pie Junkie!
This place has the most delicious pies I have EVER tasted. Just WOW!! We were gifted with a Drunken Turtle Pie from a friend of ours and it was absolutely PHENOMENAL!! We had never been there, but we will be regulars from now on.
I LOVE THIS PIE!!! Just dropped by for a B-DAY birthday piece of pie! I had a piece of Coconut Cream & Pie Smores!! Perfect start to my birthday celebrations. Oh! I also HAD to take a Drunken Turtle pie to go for our kids. Thank you so much!! See you soon. ?
Always GREAT in customer service and products offered!! I particularly appreciate the curbside delivery, as I'm often in a wheelchair with limited mobility. I live in far NW OKC, but do not mind the drive, as everything is ALWAYS so delicious!