Colton's | Steak House & Grill

565 W Shawnee St, Muskogee - 74401
215 reviews
Steak House American
(918) 910-5244

Been there twice. Once on a Saturday, once on a Monday. It's obvious that they have different quality of staff for each night, as with most restaurants. Regardless, i got steaks both nights and both were good, although the steak on Saturday was cooked more correctly to order and had a better presentation. The wait staff was good both days. If in the area again will definitely return.

I ordered a Medium Well New York Steak Salad and okra with 1/2sweet 1/2 unsweetened tea. My steak was tough and half raw at least it wasn't dripping out blood,salad was so good but not enough tomatoes and my tea was sweet. The waiter was great ..our meal somehow came up $ 63.00.My boyfriend ordered ribeye baked potato and house Salad and sweet tea....he barely got any tomatoes on Salad and his potato wasn't very big....I won't go back.But if you haven't went yet Go try it out every one is different......Have a Wonderful BLESSED Memorial Weekend.....

A pleasure as always, we are not regulars by any means, however we seem to get the same waitresses and they go above and beyond for our littles to have a great time. The bread and butter is yummy. Their steak is delicious and if you haven't tried out their wedge salad I recommend it, I typically get my dressing on the side, because I hardly eat any on it, otherwise it's drenched and messy eating. ?

Ordered the sirloin tips with mac & cheese and a garden salad. Tips were little past med rare when they got to the table BUT they were still juicy and tender. Mac & cheese was solid and the cheese sticks were very high quality. Our server was excellent. We always had drinks on the table and she checked on us frequently.

Great family restaurant featuring steaks and southern comfort food.Steaks were of nice size and cooked properly. The smashed potatoes were great.Friendly personable staff.

Food and service was very good. During the pandemic, others complained about a decline of satisfaction. But my recent visits have been great. So hopefully they are back on track! The only issue during my two recent visits were the yeast rolls way too small.

I had a steak, extremely tender, cut it with my fork, didn't even lift the knife except for moving it out of the way. Steak was good, fries was good, and the service was exceptional. Price was about averaged cost, will definitely eat here again.

Their most expensive steak is not worth the price. All I can day is that it is not the best cut. It's texture is just not right. I don't know what they do to it but don't bother if you are looking for a good steak. Their other steaks are fine and just a little over prices compared to other steak places in their price range. Their salads are fairly generous and a plus. Their chicken items are good. Service in the store is fine but take out is understaffed and not managed well at all. I am having to go inside rather than curbside because their people don't have the time to do everything. ASLO CHECK YOU TAKOUT THEY TEND TO MISS THINGS.

The worst dining experience we've ever had! So many things wrong I won't even bother listing them all, they're not going to fix them anyways. Daughter's birthday dinner and 100 bucks down the drain. We absolutely won't go back.(Saw other reviews mention hot rolls, if they had those we never got them either.)

Went to Coltons to night to celebrate my bosses 8 year old sons birthday. First off they told us it would be an hour wait but that turned out to be 2 hours. Finally got seated all was going well until we didn't get our rolls. Then we sat and listened to all the adults get their birthdays recognized. And when it came to his turn the bring him out his dessert. Needless to say this little boy walked out crying. We spend a lot of money at this restaurant. We even told the waitress when we were ordering our drinks that it was his birthday. Needless to say we will not be back.