Othello's

1 S Broadway, Edmond - 73034
234 reviews
Italian Pizza
(405) 330-9045

Can't help but think this place could use an update. Understanding this place is a staple in Edmond for YEARS I get the feeling it's still riding the wave of it's reputation from days of yore. The food was good but the price point was off. The dozen(?) Mussels my wife ordered came smothered in marinara and there wasn't much else to it. Either lower the almost $15 price, or increase the value. Guys, the place is dirty. There are splatters on the walls from what I can only assume are from other diner's pasta and sauces. Look at the walls near the back booths on the lower level and wipe them down from time to time. Look up. Dust a little. The service was on point. We had a great server and he was attentive without being pestering. The side dish of Spaghetti is awesome. You have competition down the street now.

Was a little disappointed with the restaurant. The food was good, but could have been better. We had a salad that was yummy.

John Christopher! The best server there!!!! The atmosphere of the restaurant is amazing!!! My wine is cold and bubbly just how I like it!!! The food is served hot and fresh to the table!!! The bread for the table is super tasty!!!! Big plates are given due to big prices and that is definitely ok with me!!!! Definitely treat yourself to this restaurant because the whole menu is just bomb!!!!?❤️‍??❤️‍??

I don’t like to be this person but we all grow from here. My husband and I tried this place for the first time. I got the spaghetti, hubs got chicken alfredo, we split a calamari. The spaghetti was worse than cafeteria food, the alfredo was decent, luckily the calamari was the best. Probably won’t try this place again. Best luck to the restaurant.

Family owned and run, always good quality. Gluten free options and they will work hard to adjust and adapt as needed since everything is cooked up fresh. Cocktails are always changing thanks to an experimental bar crew and owner. Nice waitstaff. Good and reliable.

If you like Italian food, you have to try this place. The food is delicious, the staff is very nice, and the rustic atmosphere is incredible.Until I tried their specialty lasagna, I never knew that lasagna could be even better with summer sausage.

When I was in college, I used to eat at the old Othello's in Norman on Campus Corner. It was very good Italian and excellent pizza. I recently moved to Edmond and thought I would give this location a try. Unfortunately it did not bring back memories of old. The sauce tasted like it came out of a can. Seriously bad with no flavor. Second the pasta was so overcooked it was thick and had a gooey texture. My pasta was supposed to have Italian sausage in it. I found 5 small pieces in my dish. My girlfriend tried the salmon. Overcooked and tasteless. It is hard to imagine the great reviews on this site are for real.

I went through my photo album on my phone and realized I never posted a review to lovely restaurant!We went here for Valentine's date night. It was so beautiful! The candles were lit, the decor was warm and inviting..Great food, great staff, empathetic and kind! It was truly great. I recommend it highly for a date.Especially if you want to woo a special someone! It worked on me! ???❤️

I've lived near here for so long and just tried it for the first time. The service was excellent and the food was delicious! Their Mariana sauce tastes fresh and I'm guessing is made in house everyday. The stuffed mushrooms with crabmeat pack a lot of amazing flavour in a small bite. If you are a fan, you must try their coconut cream pie! Never had one like it before and it completed the meal. Will be recommending this place for their pie if nothing else.

Expected more from this establishment. While on a business lunch on 3/14 I over heard employees gossip about another employee near my table. Very unprofessional of them I will not list names but I expected more from the owners. Most likely will not return and my colleagues will be leaving a review also.Over all the food was decent, drinks tasted a little watered down, might want to go to McDonald’s next time.