Uncle Vinny's NY Pizzeria

322 W Kenosha St, Broken Arrow - 74012
171 reviews
Pizza
(918) 251-6666

It was a perfect day celebrating our girl, after her dance recital- soooo, she picked this cute little Pizza Parlor for her dinner out. Thanks to the owners for making our time so special- and personalizing it, the way you did- and excellent pizza!!!! Best ever

Very wonderful people!! Went way beyond to help me find something that my daughter could have there with all her food allergies!. We love their pizza and now to find something there safe to eat! Thanks you made my day tonight and hers!

If you're looking for REAL new york pizza, this is where you get it. Spot on in every way, from the crust to the freshness, to even the prices. My cousin Nicky would love this place.

The pizza here is fresh and delicious. Not only is the food great, the staff and owners are friendly and all around wonderful people.

Keeping in mind they just re-opened after the plague, we were a bit disappointed but nothing that's not fixable next go around. Four of us agreed the crust was a little underdone but we like bubbles in our crust. We were also sad they no longer sell a 20 inch pizza. The garlic knots were a tad doughy too. The star of the show was the meatball sub. It easily feeds 2 people, is delicious, and was only 8.50. The marina tastes super fresh and delicious as well. If you want the big slices you fold over to eat, you'll need to order by the slice.

Tried twice since the original owners took back ownership. 1st time we ordered the margarita pizza, garlic knots, Greek salad, a cheese calzone, a veggie calzone, and Italian cream cake. The margarita had little to no flavor, delicious crust, garlic knots had almost no garlic and they were dry and over cooked. The Greek salad (1st and 2nd time) had way too much feta, but the salad was fresh and yummy. The cheese calzone had way too much cheese and the 2nd time was even worse and the 2nd time we couldn't even eat the cheese calzone because it was so doughy. The veggie calzone was so delicious the 1st time we had to have it the 2nd time and 2nd time they forgot the basil we asked for. Also, they use canned mushrooms in the calzone and it was not very appetizing. Their pepperoni rolls were delicious and their Italian cream cake was amazing.I would like to add that my husband noticed a difference in the cleanliness of the restaurant. He said that it had never looked better and that the staff was so incredibly polite. He said that the atmosphere was far more pleasant than before.

Okay first- The pizza we ordered was pretty good especially compared to typical rubber stamp brands. But! come on guys. I ordered onions as a side, and you literally had to find them. They literally looked like a few very thin white hairs, and obviously not enough to taste. It was actually pathetic. If you want repeat customers you need to step it up. I was looking for a good independent pizza restaurant, looks like Im still looking.

uncle vinny’s delivers to our shop often. They are friendly,fast and fresh. It’s doesn’t get better than uncle vinny’s pizza.

Just ordered and had delivered this is absolutely the best pizza place!!! Will be back not enough stars!!!!

Used to come here when I lived here 8 years ago was great to be back. Friendly laid back environment really good pizza by the slice. Also tried their dessert. Thanks!