Salvatore's Italian Grill

4831 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown - 44515
206 reviews
Italian
(330) 799-2285

This place is an overburdened staff away from being fantastic. We waited for awhile to for a table without acknowledgement from the staff, the server provided good service but lacked the friendly demeanor that makes for a good experience eating out. The food was excellent though bread and salads came out fifteen minutes after the order and no refills were offered until the meal was over. I understand that finding staff now is difficult, so I'm giving 5 stars for the effort they put forth being understaffed.

The food was delicious! Like, seriously delicious! Our server, Rachel, was amazing! They were super busy today and she was on top of everything. The bruschetta appetizer was fresh. The bread and pizza bread were both still warm when they got to the table. Our portions were bigger than I expected. I took some of it home because I couldn't finish. There were so many good options on the menu, I'll definitely go back. I want to try them all.

I was very impressed with this hidden gem. Everyone in our party enjoyed our meal and had not one complaint. The staff was great. Everyone was friendly and very respectful. The establishment was clean and well presented.

Flippin awesome food. My wife had the stuffed salmon and I had Chicken parmigiana. It was fabulous! Definately some of the best Italian food around. Great service…

By far the best food in the area. I have had the seafood fantasy, veal rockefeller, fried calamari, and calamari marinara so far. These fine people really have something going on here, fabulously prepared food. Top notch. Highly recommended 5/5 star !!!

I do not like their sauces because they lack flavor and consistency— I do love their sandwiches and salads. One of my favorite lunch spots but I could go without ever eating their pasta.

One of the best food experiences I've had in a long time. Maria C was our waitress and she was unbelievable. Fast attentive so sweet. The place just has a great atmosphere the portion sizes are so generous and absolutely delicious. I would revisit this place over and over. High quality very reasonably priced.

A year ago, I would have most happily given this establishment 5 stars. As with everything else, this restaurant is going through changes. We just finished takeout meals that have become smaller, and they are expecting a suggested 18% tip for takeout order (?) And, (I'm sure it's hectic) but once again, a part of the order was missing. Guess I just have to thank "Uncle" Joe for diminishing one of my favorite places.

Best authentic Italian food in Austintown!! Absolutely love it!

Service was great pasta not to great very running didn't drain the pasta very good