Inner Circle Pizza

1816 Boardman Poland Rd, Youngstown - 44514
162 reviews
Pizza
(330) 757-3719

Best wings ever! Cooked properly - inside the chicken was moist and tender, outside the skin was crisp and not overcooked. My only complaint, they gave me blue cheese dressing that was definitely NOT made fresh in the restaurant. It was very obviously a low-quality bottled dressing which left a lot to be desired. I'll go back but would have to bring my own blue cheese dressing.

Dinner tonight was absolutely horrible. The 3 managers were all there tonight . They said they looked at everything coming out of the kitchen. (Comical)The margarita flat bread pizza order looked like it was cooked 4 days earlier and the wings were as dry as cardboard. The kids chix tenders were extremely dry and the fries were raw. ( we sent ththeththem back 2 times to be redropped) They keep raising their prices which is fine, ( I will gladly pay any dollar amount on the menu). However their 3 managers need fired as I have had the same problems for over 6 years here. We honestly only go 2x a year for a change of pace. Which is such a mistake.The managers constantly blame the kitchen staff, but it's because of their poor training in the kitchen.Not the 16 year old cooks.That is the managers responsibility to take care of all aspects of the restaurant. To have 3 managers over 40 years old under one roof at one time to put out products like this is a joke.

Iconic Youngstown franchise. Pizza is not life-changing but solid. Wings are top notch. And don't sleep on their salads (recommend Spinach). Pictured is a Spinach pizza with sliced tomatoes added

Great food. I had the Buffalo chicken salad. The sauce on the chicken was perfect and the salad was fresh and hugeThe wait staff was attentive and friendly. Nice hometown friendly feel.

Inner Circle was absolutely wonderful. We came in a little after the lunch rush, and there weren't many people in side. Our food came out so quickly. The pizza was delicious. The wedding soup was great. We always try to stop by when were in town and I dont think Ive ever had a bad experience in the couple hundred times Ive eaten here. My sister says that they have the absolute best barbecue sauce and I love getting the Buffalo wings. You really cant go wrong.

Great Italian food ?! Service was great and everyone was very friendly and helpful!! Great job to all!! Thanks for the relaxing atmosphere, great service, and delicious food!! WTG!! I'll be back!!

Our food was great but pricey! I gave a 2 star bc we had the worst service from our waitress. Our receipt said her name was Kailee, only got a refill bc I asked another employee to get our waitress, never once did she come back and ask us how we were doing. Brought us checks along with our drinks we asked for and she didn't even bother saying anything to us, just took our card and didn't say a word.

Their Gluten sensitive pizza with pepperoni was really Gluten Free and very tasty. 10 out of 10 will order again.

White pizza, wings, and wedding soup are the best and a Y-town tradition. Never miss IC when I come back home

The waitress was excellent in her service and friendly as well. The food was very good the only reason the five was because we had to send a couple plates back due to hardly any sauce on the wings. It was remedied and the wings then we're awesome. We also love their cinnamon dip for dessert.