The Old Bag of Nails Pub - Westerville

24 North State Street # 26 # 26, Westerville - 43081
530 reviews
Pubs Seafood Burgers
(614) 794-6900

This was a return to a place I have been to before in Westerville. My fish and chips were slightly over done and my meal was quickly replaced and I did receive a surprise comp to my meal which was unexpected. Kylee my server was very pleasant, professional and customer focused. I appreciate all that was done for me today and would encourage others to go. Recommended.

The whole family enjoyed the dinner options and what they choose. Next time I would plan to order one of the fish options (what they must be known for). We ordered a couple burgers, large dinner salad, and chicken fingers. Everything was delicious and the atmosphere was great too. This restaurant is a great option for the area.

Stopped in for the first time for a Father's Day lunch and was pleasantly surprised at how everything was. Staff was friendly and everyone enjoyed their food. My wife got fish and chips was the portion was quite big, it was nicely cooked/battered and tasted great. I ordered the blackened cod reuben-style sandwich and absolutely loved it. There was a choice between getting the cod blackened or baked and blackened was definitely the way to go. The spices were so good and the bread was delicious too.Kids also eat free on Sunday's too which is a nice plus. We'll definitely be back!

Morgan sat me immediately and took my drink order. My friend arrived a bit later and she was at the table as soon as he sat down. She gave us a few minutes to decide on what to order.The food arrived shortly and was delicious.Morgan continued to check on us and made sure everything was good.Overall a very nice experience.

Not worth the visit. food was either overcooked or undercooked. Took forever to get food as in near an hour. Soup was good. but the unlimited soup isn't worth the cost 20 mins between bowls is too long. salads was alot of stems. I personal won't be back.

I had the mussels and shrimp dish which was very good. My friend had a sandwich and it was terrible. The worse part though was that our waitress smelt like she took a bath in marajuana it was overwhelming and off putting

Great place for good food - always a good time here. On my latest trip, we hosted an event in their third floor event space (attached pictures) which was just as wonderful.

Food was not very good. Got the pretzel and cheese- cheese was cold, TONS of butter. Lobster bisque soup was not good and also not warm. The spinach salad was good but the vinaigrette was VERY strong and sour. Service was friendly, but not very fast. Ordering a beer was 5 mins at least and there was only 3 tables, and we were already at the bar...

One of the worse fish sandwich ever. No toasted buttered bun. Fish was soggy and batter fell off. I asked for lettuce and tartar sauce. No lettuce.I expected better from this establishment from the reviews.

Food was amazing!! Service was great and it was obvious they were short staffed ( like so many place now days), but they managed to do a great job! And remained so kind. I will definitely be back!!!