Carsonie's

6000 Westerville Rd, Westerville - 43081
196 reviews
Pizza Italian
(614) 899-6700

We were just driving by and looking for a place for lunch and found Carsonie's. Saturday afternoon not busy at all. Waitress was very friendly and helpful. Recommended the Strom and it did not disappoint. Also had sweet heat wings and garlic parm which were yummy. The marinara is awesome. We ordered the large strom and split it along with the wings between the wife and I and took some of the strom home. Good stuff.

Disappointing service and food, definitely won’t be back. We went for my dad’s birthday, and there were 14 of us. We made reservations way in advance, so it was definitely no surprise. I only ever saw one server, and he was trying his best. He accidentally ordered the wrong meal for me, so he said it was being remade. I didn’t get my sub, no joke, until every single person was finished eating. When the bill came, they charged us full price for everything. When I politely asked if they would be willing to remove just my meal (that I barely ate because, hello, who wants to eat with 13 people watching them). The manager apparently said that the best they could do was half. We’re talking $6. I tipped the kid well; I don’t think it was his fault, but I’ll never go back. I don’t imagine any of those 13 other people (or our couple hundred bucks) will either. So disappointed.

Ordered a white pizza with extra spinach and cheese. No extra spinach, Corey took it off the check. Ordered two Bacardi and cokes tall. Up charged $2.00 to be tall. Really !! Not again, $1.00 per drink for 2 cents of coke. B/S !! There is more, given the check. It had our order on it and someone else's order on our tab. $74.00. Corey had a flip it attitude about it. He was rewarded accordingly.

Food was really good. Sat at the bar and had an excellent old fashioned. Didn't have a to wait that long for my takeout orderMy lasagna was delicious. As was my wife's chicken parm. Also had fried pickles and calamari all delicious

Had a delightful lunch there with my daughter. Great service and our food was fantastic!! You won't be disappointed!

Best Stromboli ever hands down! My family and I have been coming here since I was 10 and there used to be a dollar movie behind here that we would go to afterwards. The Stromboli is my favorite dish here and it's always made fresh. Staff have always been super friendly and make you feel welcome!

We ordered a deep dish 1/2 veggie, 1/2 pepperoni pizza. When I got there to pick it up, the pizza was completely wrong. They don’t even have a deep dish pizza and no one informed us until we were in to pick it up. The toppings were wrong. The fries and mozzarella sticks were both cold. Nothing here was good. Stay away!!

Great food and service. We showed up about 30 minutes before closing and they were kind enough to fix our food and wait on us. We'll definitely go back!

Nice variety of selections. Waitress was attentive. Food was delicious. Drink specials looked appealing, but I did not indulge this time.

Service was awesome. I believe his name was Corey and he was excellent. Salad and stromboli were excellent but sadly the sub was not.