Winking Lizard Reynoldsburg

7995 E Broad St, Reynoldsburg - 43068
315 reviews
American Salad
(614) 490-3070

Loved our waiter, but sauce on the Buffalo sandwich was very light, pickles were Luke warm and as some side advice; it would be good to bill out meals with dressing included, even if price is higher. Nobody wants to see 3 charges of ranch or blue cheese when there should be an acceptable amount that comes with the meal. Otherwise, great place would come back to try out other food. Will come back and adjust rating depending on follow up experiences.

During our outing today, we found Winking Lizard tucked away at the end of a strip mall. Advertised as similar to Walhburgers. Had to give it a try. 5⭐ for sure. Large menu selection, so many dishes to try. Our meal today was a spectacular Grilled Chicken Teriyaki, with baked beans, steamed broccoli and garlic bread. Flavor, incredible. Portion size great for the price. Our Waiter was friendly, took good care of us. Atmosphere was comfortable, even though the place was busy, we didn't feel crowded. There was no end to the wall of flat screens. Enjoyed the experience and will return.

I was taken to lunch by a work colleague, and she chose Winking Lizard. Service was a little slow, but we were a table of six, and with COVID, I didn’t think too much of it. I ordered the steak and asparagus salad—it was excellent! Steak was rare as I requested, and the asparagus was cooked nicely too. One woman had the Carolina pulled pork sandwich, one woman had boneless wings and fries, both loved their selections. One woman ordered a burger, and she said it was over-done and dry. But the fries were amazing! The looked great—crispy on the outside and soft inside. All a good choice for lunch—I’m glad Max & Erma’s was closed!

We have had great service good food! what more can you ask for?

I got take out from here, The Pfred’s Preferred Pfries ($7.29) and 10 Plain Wings w/Mild Sauce on the side($13). The food was pretty good, I bet the dine in is even better. the service was quick as well! I will definitely be back.

If you are looking for a variety of food and a sports/chill atmosphere, this is a great spot. I've never been disappointed by any of the food, and the seasonal drinks are always good! Just as much personality as the one in Cleveland, just not as loud. lol

so, we were given no silverware, only original glasses of water, wife enjoyed her salad and grilled cheese. I ordered the fish sandwich, which was more batter than fish, and the batter was hard and little fish there was didn't taste good. our waiter said he was swamped with a group of 13 so he didn't get to us. it was for me a sad experience, the first really bad one here. oh and they seated us in the bar, where the music and noise was too loud. could I have said anything? yes except we saw no one until it was time for the bill. he asked how the meal was, I said not very good, and he left to get the carry out box for my wife. not an experience I would recommend.

Absolute gem of a place!! Has everything you could want and more.Service 10/10 super friendly staff, always checking in with us and sweet.Food 10/10 we got the lizard freckles (deep fried pickle chips) and the western burgers with loaded fries. Was more than enough food and took what we did not eat home.Price 10/10 food was price fairly and really above and beyond.The place itself was also very clean and nice. Wish we had one closer to were I lived. It's a must stop from here on out for me and my friends :) can't wait to go back

The food was delicious. I had the BBQ chicken with fries and coleslaw and my wife had the battered Haddock (highly recommend, it was cooked perfectly). The staff was wonderful and attentive and lots of TVs for March Madness.

Went for drinks with my lady a few evenings ago. Our server was nice, but the drinks weren’t worth the price considering they tasted like they only put half of a splash of alcohol in them. One of the drinks tasted like what I imagine lizard piss would taste like. Maybe that can be attributed to the fact their menu is beer heavy. Wouldn’t go back unless at gun point.