Tylers Pizzeria Is usually really good. I gave them 3 stars this time because the Margherita pizza I ordered had no flavor. When I picked up a slice all the toppings fell off into the box and the pizza looked like it was cut by a 5 hear old. Once I added some Salt and pepper to the pizza it tasted much better. I also ordered the potato focaccia which had half the amount of potatoes as the last time I ordered it. I like to order it and save it for breakfast the next day and top it with a poached or over easy egg. It won't be the same without all the potato. Again none of this is typical of Tyler's. Pretty disappointing.
Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery is a jewel of reynoldsburg. Everything is fresh and delicious. Tyler is usually back in the bakery working very hard - but is a very personable, laid back guy. You can tell he cares alot about the bakery and isn't in it for the money.The staff are all great and are very helpful. The Pizza is WONDERFUL. Just make a note - we aren't talking mass production hot and fresh pick ups. You need to order in advance because the secret is getting out - and he only has so many wood fired ovens. If you are looking for a 6-7pm pizza pickup on a busy night, like friday or saturday - call when they open and place that order.
The best pizza. I love the oven brick flame pizzas and I love the half and half pizzas they offer for my husband and I can get what we like and the kids can get what they like. Everyone is always very nice and try their best to get you what you are looking for. Give them a try!
Pizza was amazing. Pauper's with fresh garlic was absolutely perfect. Smelled and tasted amazing. 100% will be back.
Oh, gosh. They have a baked potato pizza in the fall I add jalapenos and it's so giving. I love everything they make. They use good quality ingredients and it show. Friendly staff good wholesome baked goods and different flavors of pizza you would never dream of.
Great pizza and awesome calzones! Wish I would have found this place when it was a bit warmer out, there is a cute patio area out front.
Absolutely amazing. I've been going here regularly for 4 years. Every item is superb.
Love my pauper white pizza, also the calzone pauper. Had a pepperoni roll, omg to die for. Only place I go for that
Love this little place! The staff is always friendly and the food is just next level! Also its crazy affordable which is wild because the ingredients are top tier. Will be back
Tried Tyler’s pizza bc of the name. Came back for the crust! The dough is always perfectly cooked. We’ve tried the Stromboli and pizza, can go wrong with pepperoni.I would say that I wouldn’t recommend the Margherita. It lacked flavor in my opinion. Needed salt and oregano.But overall I like this place, they have low prices for how great the quality of dough on the pizzas. Staff is friendly.