Pizza Cottage

8753 Owenfield Dr, Powell - 43065
100 reviews
Pizza Salad Chicken Wings
(740) 879-3001

If this pizza is good, then the Little Caesars $5 hot & ready pizza is gourmet. The crust is like cardboard and the sauce was nonexistent. I actually thought I was eating the cardboard the pizza sits on. This was my first and last time trying this pizza. If pizza today magazine as advertised on the side of their box is a real thing, you just lost all credibility. Scale of 1-10. This is a 1 and only a 1 because of the cheese. The wings were terrible as well, like they had been sitting on a buffet all day.

1st time there. Overall taste of the food was great. Ordered med. cheese pizza and "APPETIZER" order of fries. Says right on the menu "ENOUGH TO SHARE". When they came out there were about 15 fries. Very small portion. Covered about 40% of the bottom of the basket. My 2 1/2 year old ate every single one and he hardly eats anything. Asked the waiter what size order of fries it was and he said it was the appetizer and agreed there didn't seem to be that very many there. My wife asked if we could just get a little more since it was almost $4 and said enough to share. He said he would see what he could do. He came back and told us he couldn't get us anymore fries but could maybe give a little discount on the bill. As we left I went to front desk and asked for the manager. I proceeded to tell her what happened and advised her it was a bad business decision to choose to give us a $1.77 discount over just a little more fries is all we were asking for. She stood up straight, put her hands on her hips and told me that a bad business decision would be to just give everybody stuff for free and told me good luck. I couldn't believe how she reacted and just never in my life been told no by a waiter about something for something he actually agreed upon in the 1st place. The manager also told me that all the fries are pre-weighed in the mornings so she couldn't change the amount of fries in the order. I find that hard to believe that they are pre-weighed out. It sucks because my family liked the food and the waiter was actually very good. The manager shouldn't be the manager if she reacted to me as nice as I was actually being about it. Not sure if we will return

Our pizzas were really good but there was only 1 server and so we waited 10 minutes before the server even noticed we were there. And it was another 5 minutes before he greeted our table. There was no hostess and the sign said to seat yourself. I even purposely went around to find a table up front so that he would know we were there.

We stopped in and had wings, salad, and pizza and two appetizers. Wings were mild and cooked perfectly, large Italian salad was delicious. The highlight was the pizza . Got a double pepperoni and it was fantastic. I will definitely be eating there again. I highly recommend this place.

Great place for my family to relax and enjoy our selves. My son got to watch cartoons and we got to eat in peace. They have TVs at every table. The wings were great and my son ate ALL his pizza. The staff is very fast and friendly. We MOST definitely will be back for more good times and great food. HIGHLY RECOMMEND.

We have tried this location several times lately only to receive bad services. Paid for pizza in advance went to pickup at stated time only to have to wait another half hour because it wasn't even made very upset no one cared .we have driven 1 hour away to buckeye lake location it's worth it .lewis center store needs serious help

this was out first time and we were surprised at gow good it was ...We will eat here again

Especially liked the Wednesday special when it was buy one large and got 50% off. Now you need to buy 2 to get 50% off one. Not too practical for 2 people.

Its not bad pizza, just very much not my favorite.$11 small (10") blk olive, mushroom.First, i like wedge slices where each slice has a crist = handhold...these were tiny gooy squares.Second, the toppings were plentiful. At first glance I thought the shrooms were fresh. The mouth feel and closer inspection reveals they are likely canned, just not the typical squishy grey-brown familiar "slices".Third, the sauce /seasoning. Pretty sure the seasoning (the green stuff) is all on top, not at all in the sauce. Thesauceday be "seasoned" meaning salt, pepper, and sugar, but otherwise, its just crushed tomatoes.There is a sour after taste.Just not my fav pie.

Good service and food. I would recommend to anyone