I was just delivered the worst pizza I've ever had in my life from P.Jays. It was a speciality pizza called Sicilian Sausage. When you bake a pizza with sausage on it, the grease will exit the sausage, and filter down to the crust. Imagine a pizza crust filled with uncooked sausage and what would happen. And that's exactly what I got. A grease laden crust so wet, and disgusting, you could actually pick up a piece and watch grease drip from it. Never ever again.
Used to love this place, would get it 1 or 2 times a week, the past few months it has been very inconsistent and either very good, or just not edible. Tried ordering tonight at 8:50 (they close at 930), to someone picking the phone up and hanging up immediately, then not picking up the phone at all the next 2 times i call. Sad to say i will not be back. Plenty of other pizza joints around town to eat at.
Fantastic Pizza and a Great Staff. The BBQ chicken is unique the way they make it. I recommend
The pizza is hit or miss. When it's good it's really good, when it's bad it's really bad. We have had good experiences ordering the sheet pizza's for parties, as well as their specialty pizzas. The pickle pizza, sounds strange but so good. I wish I knew why there was inconsistency at times with regular pizza's, but they are not the only business that goes through that, so I will continue to go there occasionally.
Ordered two large pizzas which are typically 14 inches in diameter and received two what looked like medium pizzas 12 inches in diameter.The sauce has little bits of onion in it which some may like but i found it disgustingThe mozzarella cheese had a sour milk taste.Pepperoni had no flavor... like turkey pepperoni.Just another little pizza shop who make a sport to screw with new customers.Not much better than the pizza at Speedway.Better ask a lot of questions before handing over your money... and if they smart just walk out. PLENTY of other places.
Worst pizza. I couldn't even eat it. I went to pull a piece & it was so soggy.. fell apart. I dont know why my boyfriend didn't return the 2 pizzas he purchased. Luckily I had corned beef to eat. He just said we won't be going back.
first time ordering delivery was fast,food was hot, everything was delicious. love the dipping sauce
Got a jumbo pepp, saus, mush , and onion tonight. Outstanding pizza. The best in Parma. Even called back to let them know how good it was.
Pizza was soggy. I couldn't even eat it. Will never try again.
Great depending on who is working. The younger crew are not good at making pizza.