Panther Pizza & Bakery

2448 W High St NE, Newark - 43055
95 reviews
Pizza
(740) 763-3111

We used to love this place, had a bad experience a few months ago and decided to try it again tonight. The amount of sauce on the pizza makes it almost inedible. The cheese distribution (or lack thereof) is sad. The only good thing about the experience tonight was the speed of the delivery. The owner and staff are very nice and the baked goods are on point. I’m not sure what has happened to this place over the years but it’s unfortunate, the pizza just isn’t worth the money anymore.

$60 order tonight $65 total w delivery tip and my sub was wrong”again” I called and they offered to bring me a new one but was taking the other one back,um no #1 legally with Covid you’re not allowed to take food back,#2 we already waited an hr for the sub my son was eating it so I ask for a credit on next order(we order regularly) and was offered $3 on a $15 sub…lol… u messed up my order and ur offering $3 back NO THANK YOU,u lost a customer. It’s sad when u try to keep ur money in small local businesses and get this treatment,for now on if I’m spending $60 for pizza I will just take my family to Texas Road house cause it would be cheaper ;)

You call that a $7 salad how sad, haven’t even taken a bit yet. Will never order a salad from here again!

Amazing pizza! First time here and will definitely be back for more!

Good food, friendly service, reasonable prices.

Have not had panther in years, decided to get it last night and after almost $50, I was extremely disappointed. The BLT hardly had anything on it except mayo and pizza sauce. It was thrown out. Used to be my favorite BLT. Our other pizza was not as bad but felt like I was just eating pizza crust. Staff and service was great but food was not.

Absolutely amazing staff!! Plus the food is fabulous!

Was very good will be back

Panther Pizza never disappoints. The staff treat everyone like family, the quality is fantastic, the portions are generous. There’s something for everyone!

Great food and cheese bread! Can't wait to try the deep dish pizza!