Pizza is a 5. Delivery is a 0. I live in the same little village where they are but their delivery radius is super tight. I can get there in 5 min!I grew up eating this pizza. DeFelice is from shadyside oh, I'm from Bellaire, the town next door. There's nothing like valley pizza and I hope they survive here. But I doubt they will if they don't deliver.
We love their pizza and get at least one a week good stuff!
We ordered from this place twice as the first one seemed like it wasn't cooked long enough so we wanted to give it a fair chance and ordered again a month or so later. The second pizza was cooked longer and had a good flavor. Nothing special but the price was OK for what you get.
I tried this pizza place for the first time tonight and it is the best pizza I’ve had in Newark! The delivery was insanely fast and I love how much cheese is added to the pizza. I highly recommend. Reasonable prices as well!
I got a pepperoni pizza and their garlic cheese bread. The pizza was way over sauced and greasy for my taste, and the garlic cheese bread looked nothing like the website and I honestly didn’t even want to eat it. It looked over cooked and hardly any cheese. I was super disappointed :(
I ordered through Doordash and the driver decided to keep one of my pizzas. So I called in and Scott was so nice, he called Doordash for me to get it taken care of. My boys and I enjoyed the food we did get! I highly recommend giving this place a chance!!
The food was delicious and you can taste that fresh ingredients are used! I added ricotta cheese to my pizza and it was a nice twist. The ribeye steak sub was wonderful! Definitely recommend!!
After my favorite place in town started going down hill I turned to these guys and I will never look back. Best pizza in Newark ! They also delivered to my family in the snow on a holiday. I’d give more stars if I could.
I am really enjoying Defelice Pizza. Their pizzas are really good, but I absolutely love their calzones. They also have really great cookies. The staff are fun and the owner is super nice. I order from them at least twice a month.
I am not exaggerating when I say this was the worst pizza experience of my life. We waited just shy of 3 hours for a large pizza and received over an inch thick burnt crust with no sauce and cold cheese on top. Disappointed doesn't touch it.