City Grille

37 E 4th St, Mansfield - 44902
156 reviews
American
(419) 709-9199

I used to love this place until we ordered pick up the other day. My chicken fettuccine had no chicken and stuck together like paste. The lettuce was brown and slimy. The salad screamed "food poisoning ". ☠️ The buffalo chicken dip also had no chicken and was nothing more than buffalo sauce with stale chips. It was terrible. Not one item was fresh or prepared properly. I called and left a voicemail letting them know about the poor quality and noone has yet to call back. It's been over 24hrs. What a waste of $40.

The ambiance, history is really cool and the server was nice. However, the food was not good. The celery was wilted and the lettuce in the salad was brown. I ordered the salmon - it was over cooked. My partner ordered the wings - he said they were good. It was our first time there, so maybe bar food is the specialty. We had family from Canada with us and their meal was not good either. We won't return to dine.

I am torn, we had a party of 15, and they were clearly under-staffed, it was clean (ish), and I appreciate being under-staffed, but we waited an hour to get water. I had to go the bar to get our waters, we had other drinks with a thumbs up from the server to get more water, I still got my own, after an hour. All the staff was busting their butts, but.. Decrease capacity or pay more.....

Stopped here for lunch while passing through town. Food was excellent. Great service. Definitely stop if your in the area.

I didn’t think the food was great, but we did have fun while there. Our server was really nice and interacted with us.

I believe the bartender's name is Tim he does a phenomenal job this place is a really cool place in the heart of Mansfield

Not to busy on a Thursday evening. Our waitress was very nice and prompt to ensure our glasses were full. I got the Tots with cheese and bacon. Not a fan, tots were hard, cheese was hard and all were stuck together. The fish tacos were great though.

We had our office Christmas party here and it was nice. We sat upstairs, the service was good as well as the food. Definitely recommend eating here!

We stopped in for a late lunch early dinner on our day out and the inside was very pretty and comforting. If you’re sensitive to light I don’t recommend sitting in the middle of the restaurant at 3 pm but the view is nice. I had crab cakes cole slaw and loaded tater tots. The crab cakes were hot and delicious but the cole slaw tasted really off, I said something to our lovely server Emily who handled the situation really well, who had them bring out a fresh bowl that tasted a lot better. My husband had the cheese steak and tots, and we will surely be coming back even if the next time is just for drinks and appetizers. All and all a lovely place to dine out for a relaxing lunch or a romantic evening.

Absolutely amazing crab cakes with sweet potato fries!! What was the sauce we dipped the fries in? So awesome ? great staff and atmosphere. Cook brought the plates to the table which was an even better plus ? definitely will be back