Pizza Cottage

2223 W Fair Ave, Lancaster - 43130
155 reviews
Pizza Salad Chicken Wings
(740) 654-2400

It's not cheap, but who is these days. The food was excellent, pre-order and picked-up at window. Fast service, nice smile.

Staff was wonderful!! Unfortunately the pizza is pretty blah. They've changed a few things and not for the better. Cheesy bread sticks were junk, ingredients seemed cheaper, and the beer selection was very sub par. Overall atmosphere needs updated....not homey or comfortable in any way.

Food was great but the service was excellent! Hannah was a great server. When I asked for no cheese she made sure it was not because I had an allergy. Service like she gives is hard to find these days!

Waitress was friendly and efficient. Took very good care of us. French fries were yummy. Pizza delicious.

We love getting the take and bake. The regular crust is a little thin so we're trying the thicker option next time. They seriously use the freshest ingredients!!! So good!

It was pretty good pizza, not so much the calzone. They were out of Alfredo sauce and tossed the Tea before I could get a refill. We got to hang out with our friends, so that made it worth it.

We had a large group and the waitress was great. Best veggie pizza in town!

Last minute Bday party. Food is always good. Service was really really good. Thank you so much for the last minute bailout.

I ordered their 12" loaded pizza with a few substitutions in toppings thin Crust & light well done. Turned out exactly as I wanted light sauce, crunchy crust, darker edges but toppings not burnt. YUMMY !!My favorite pizza stop !

Waitress was on point. The kitchen needs some work. Everything was good. It just took a really long time to get wings