Amazing food! I tried every meal we had on the table as a family and everything tasted amazing and all had a homemade touch and was all hot and fresh! We had the most amazing waitress name Emily! She was on top of her game! She was so so sweet and always smiling.. she always checked on her tables and you never had to ask for a refill on top of that she was so patient with my two small children and treated them wonderfully as well. I also love the whole feel and decor and vibe of the restaurant… it just feels happy and homey. Not only was our food amazing but Emily made our experience perfection. Definitely will be returning!!!! 12 out of 10!!!!!!! Thank you cherry street pub and thank you Emily for being you !!!!!
A hidden gem, this restaurant had beautiful decor, fun and friendly atmosphere & absolutely delicious food. We were passing through on our travels, I’m glad we stopped by here for lunch. ✨
PB&J wings? GET THEM. Hands down the most delicious appetizer we had during our weekend trip to Hocking Hills. The wings were cooked just right, not too much peanut butter, not too much jelly, all just RIGHT! The carrots and celery made me feel less guilty about it and healthier. The atmosphere was super cool. The bartender was great! She made a delicious two drinks for us. I can't remember the names but they were a good ratio of alcohol and juice. The service was quick! The place was clean. Super easy street parking. I had the smothered burrito in a bowl without the tortilla. He had a burger but also made it into a bowl without the bun. The whole experience was great that we are already planning our trip back toward the end of this month. Check out Lancaster! It's a cute little town. We love it here.
I ordered the Cherry Street Lemonade and it was very good. My husband ate the Beast burger and said it was one of the best burgers he's had. My burger was the Bayou Burger and it was good but I was already a bit tipsy from my lemonade so my judgement may have been impaired. ?
The food and service were both AMAZING!Prices and names for all the food are great. Mixed drinks are yummy and affordable also. Not to mention the decor is awesome and has a hometown feel. Everyone knows Everyone! You wont regret coming here! I suggest Kylie, Kristen, and Samantha as your servers they were great .
My friend and I visited this restaurant for our first time over the weekend, and we had a wonderful time. The atmosphere was relaxing and fun and the place is adorable inside! Our server was fantastic, although I can't remember her name, she had very short red hair and was one of the best servers we've had before. The food was great and comes in large portions so we will definitely share a meal next time! Overall, it was an awesome experience and we will be regular customers here!
The quick summary is that Cherry Street Pub is worthy of a stop if you find yourself in Lancaster or on your way to Hocking Hills or Athens, or even a day trip from Columbus. It’s just a few minutes off the main drag so don’t be dissuaded from going based on your map app. It’s easy to dismiss small and medium sized town establishments when traveling or with limited time but that’s selling short opportunities such as Cherry Street Pub. I was drawn here because of the new owners’ other wonderful restaurants in the greater Columbus area. I appreciate their effort to bring, or in this case, maintain, an above average option that will satisfy locals and visitors alike. I’m a fan of small town old school settings and Cherry St does not disappoint. The bar itself (you know, the area behind the bartender) is a beautifully maintained antique from the early 20th century. The rest of the pub is equally maintained and exceptionally clean. This includes the men’s room which tells you the staff puts a lot of care into the place. Food wise, the Rueben I had was definitely better than most for no other reason than it was crisp example of how a Rueben should be. (I was torn between the Rueben and the pork tacos which were described to me as locally sourced and smoked. I’ll be back for these another day.) I had a side of tatter tots and, again, they were crispy - not something you always expect with bar food. Overall, the menu presents many options that are a step or two above what you see at other places. Cherry St Pub offers a good selection of draught macro and craft beers including some local/regional choices. The liquor selection was just as good featuring many better labels in every category. The service was excellent. I sat at the bar where the bartender spent time helping me make food and drink choices along with giving me a little bit of the long history of the place. I interacted with a couple other staff member who were all friendly and helpful. As I said, go there, support a local business, and enjoy the atmosphere, food, drinks and service. It’s really easy to get there and worth the time.
Fairly long wait time, but that's understandable because we were there on Sunday a little after noon. I had the Reuben, my wife had the fish sandwich, and our older daughter had macaroni and cheese. Everything was well prepared and cheerfully served.
I ordered the Beast burger and my husband got the Reuben sandwich and we also got the Calamari appetizer. The service was excellent, we never had to wait for drink refills. Everything was seasoned well and tasted amazing. Will definitely be back!
Great service and great apps