Castaways

1500 N High St, Lancaster - 43130
144 reviews
Pizza American Seafood
(740) 654-9197

My husband and I were the first customers of the evening. We were seated at a table and ordered drinks. When our waitress came in back to take our dinner order, we asked if the blaring music could be turned down. She checked with the owner who said they could not. We asked if they could turn it off and I once again were told no. We moved to another table. We are a retired couple who were expecting a nice evening. Restrooms are filthy. Foodstraight from freezer to deep fryer. Won't be back.

Love the employees. Food is always fantastic and the wait is never long if there even is one. Great place.

We had 2 waitresses. One was very nice the other who took our order was very short with us and rude. Yes they were busy but no reason to be rude. My husband and I both ordered steaks. Neither was cooked right and had no flavor, he ordered a side of mushrooms, they were literally a CAN of sliced mushrooms dumped in a cup. Ew. We spent $75 and we both left still hungry. Very disappointed to say the least.

Great food and service! We ordered the steak for 3 my goodness was it a mound of steak and delicious too! Our first time there and we all said we would definitely come back.

They are very attentive and the food was great and fast

Wow is all I can say! We came here for our anniversary dinner last weekend with our child and my mom. I never expected such a delicious meal! We were all super impressed ? we all had steaks, they were cooked PERFECT and delicious. We will definitely come back here. I wish we would have known about this place sooner! our wait time for our food was incredible! I have never been served so fast. It was later in the evening, it wasn't jam packed but still enough people I couldn't believe it when she sat our food down and it was so hot. Such a wonderful atmosphere. THANK YOU for making our anniversary perfect ?

Never disappointed. Food tastes great. Atmosphere wonderful. Service always friendly. Support Local and you'll never be let down. One of my favorite restaurants to visit when home to see family.

Pizza crust was soaked in some kind of liquid and especially middle of crust was soggy and not edible. My wife's hashbrowns looked and tasted old or something? Salads had good dressings. Probably won't try it again.

Staff was great. All my food tastes like grease

Super great meal .The big Dave is delicious and fresh.My wife had the scrumptious hand made potato skins. highly recommend the pizza too. A place we frequent often.