Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern

3901 Britton Pkwy, Hilliard - 43026
267 reviews
American Pubs Comfort Food
(614) 777-5868

Joey was a great waiter and the food was delicious. Happy hour prices were the cherry on top!

Enjoyable casual dining with friendly service. Terrific value on half price wine bottle night.

Overall not bad. Figured it would be more crowded on Father’s Day. Food was hot. Drinks were good.

The staff was friendly and polite. We were seated right away. We waited a long time to get our meal. When it came, my food was cold. I understand that there may be a shortage of help at the restaurant; however, the cold food did not equal the price I paid. I was disappointed in my meal. I will go back to this restaurant because the food is usually very good. One off night will not keep me from making a return trip.

ordered fish n chips got 1 piece of fish and 1 small piece of chicken. $ 18.99 Told the manager she offered a piece of fish. said no. We had already waited 45 minutes on our food and they hadn't got busy yet. I was in the bar and food business. I know what I would have done and I know what a good manager would have done. Won't be going back for some time if ever

fish and chips were OK but the fish tacos were not. The fish was dry, overcooked and not hot

Didn't seem like a very welcoming place. The tuna in the Poke bowl didn't seem fresh and the overall flavor was awful. Wings and chicken strips were good. Slow service, didn't check on us much and never asked if we liked the food. Even after taking our plates and MI e had barely been touched. Won't be back.

We ordered this to go last night and overall this is a place to skip.The rigatoni is $16.29 and was the smallest portion of pasta I have seen from a restaurant. I have added a photo with a size comparison, my Kroger card takes up the majority of the pasta bowl, and for the price that's unacceptable. It came with what I assume is garlic bread, but had absolutely no garlic flavor to it and was burnt. It was absolutely awful. The pasta itself was good just not worth the five bites you get of it.My burger was too salty and over cooked but tasted fine.In a pinch, this isn't a bad option but for what they charge there are better options.

We were disappointed with our service. When we put in our order, it was 45 minutes before we got our food. No one ever stopped by to tell us there was a delay. It was disappointing.

I understand staff shortages, but I guess there comes a point where if you continue to let patrons in with said shortages, the food and the service will ultimately suffer, which is what I believe happened on our visit.