Large all the way 29$? 60 minutes, parking is very difficult, you are going to get blocked in or you are walking to location.? Waiting area was small and with covid I stood outside. Pizza was VERY greasy, the box was oily on top and bottom. Thin box! My seat was oily by the time I arrived back to the house. No dining area, this place is a pick up and go. The edge of the pizza was great however, the center wasn't eat able as it wasn't cooked and very greasy to pick up.. We were able to roll it and squeeze the grease out.. ? sausage was good pep good but all in all not worth the almost 30$. The salad was just a pile of lettuce no dressing, no tomato, no cheese, no pep, nothing but lettuce that was pulled apart? ? CASH Only * which is going to be a problem sooner then later as most of the west coast is card only, cash will be a thing of the past.
Was out this way for work with my brother and we weren’t sure what to get for dinner so we stumbled across this place online saw some decent reviews so figured we would give it a shot and ordered a pizza for pickup.. was a little inconvenient finding out they only accepted cash but we managed to scrape up enough to cover the za and took it back to the hotel. Now let me tell you people.. This might be the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life. Something about the crust had a flavor or texture or something that was unlike anything else. It was absolutely wonderful, my brother and I both felt the same way. The two of us ate the entire extra large pizza in one sitting. Can’t wait to be back in this area in the future for more of this heavenly pie.
First time here and last. Burnt! funny shaped pizza straight outta the oven!! Nice work guys!! The toppings were a mess not evenly distributed barely any sauce. The cheesy bread is just a sub bun with a huge glob of cheese on it. No real flavor. You could barely swallow the cheesy breads cheese it felt like chewing on rubber. Bland and disgusting! I didn't even bother to call and complain i wouldn't of wanted another. Keep my "CASH!" too not worth the drive back. Do yourself a favor and avoid this place at all costs.
Terrible pizza! You know it’s bad, when little kids won’t eat it.Ordered an extra cheese pizza and nothing about it was good. Sauce was bitter, flavorless, and left a greasy aftertaste. The crust taste like cardboard, and it really didn’t seem extra cheesy. The family refused to eat it, and I ended up buying the same type of pizza from another pizza place.Also, the only take cash, which was an inconvenience. This was not even worth the ATM fee I had to pay to get the cash for it. Not sure why this is a 4.5 star place. Maybe because it holds sentimental value to locals.
Incredible pizza and very friendly/helpful staff.
Let me tell you - I love Zammy's. They have some of the best pizza in all of Columbus. The only downside is they haven't modernized. And this isn't necessarily a bad thing - I love a classic mom and pop pizza shop. I think the lack of accepting credit cards and still taking orders on pen and paper is a little bit too antiquated. I've heard that the owners don't want to pay a 3% credit card fee or pay for a Point of Sale terminal for taking orders. As a customer and someone's whose family has been coming here for years, I would gladly pay an extra $2-3 on a pizza if it meant I could pay with a credit card. Their loyal customer base is plentiful, and some small modern changes would do wonders for their business.
Fantastic local pizza joint! They offered generous toppings and a taste better than pizzas that are $10 more expensive!It is clear that lots of local kids work here as a part time job, and you can tell it's a Grove City favorite by how many customers line up at this small shop!Note that the restaurant is take out only (there is no seating) and they only accept cash or check (no credit cards).
We always have a delightful pizza night when we order from Zamarelli's. Top notch. Reasonable pricing.
Best square cut pie I've ever had. Love the old family charm of the business. Great customer service. Affordable too.
Delicious pizza and breadsticks! We had mushrooms, sausage, pepperoni and banana peppers and everything was very tasty. The sausage has great flavor. This place is a hidden gem, old school and has reasonable pricing. We ordered ahead on a Saturday night and the pizza was ready in 30 minutes. Totally recommend. Will eat again!