Tammy's Pizza - Hoover at Rt-665

5913 Hoover Rd, Grove City - 43123
128 reviews
Pizza
(614) 875-8525

Only the third time I ordered from Tammy's pizza. Pizza has been really good. Service not so much. This third time was an online timed order to be ready at 7pm. I only get 30 minutes for lunch...when I got there to pick up my order I was told 5 more minutes till it was ready. After waiting 10 minutes my order was ready. I didn't even get to eat my pizza and the cheese on my twisty fries was burnt. Dont think it matters what day of the week it is......its a timed order. Should have been ready.

Tammy's pizza has changed with the new owners. Consistent quality is no longer there. Wait times are various and web orders seem to pad times so your order sits due to algorithms not working correctly. Another items that seems to be removed is the corn meal from the dough so the pizzas seems to bake differently now. Still OK, but not 5 star like it used to be.

Delish! I ordered a gluten free pepperoni and man, it didn’t disappoint! Very friendly staff and wonderful food.

I had a large sausage, extra cheese and extra extra sauce the other night. That the BEST pizza I have had in years. You will be my new spot when it comes to pizza.

Placeda large order which include 4 XL pizzas, subs & bread sticks. The order was prompt, accurate and of course DELISH!! The employee at the front desk super friendly and Thanked me for donating items for the food drive they were sponsoring. Tammy's is under new ownership they have not missed a beat! If anything they have improved their visabilty not to mention added menu items and online ordering! Thank you!

5 star rating good customer service

Thought the overall pie was great, just skimpy on the onions. I can never understand why the cheapest thing on the menu has to be put on so sparingly. Otherwise, sauce/cheese/ pepperoni and sausage were great. Young lady working was very personable.

The service, order accuracy and food are spot on. Highly recommend!!!!

Pizza is usually cooked incorrectly which melts to paper in the box. Never had a pizza that has this problem. They also employ children who are instructed to refer to the owners rather than have any sort of employee empowerment to resolve issues. Owners only show up after hours to collect money. They don't care at all whats wrong with your experience. They refused to refund me for my pizza, never offered to remake it, and then after 2 days of trying to contact owners actually tried to blame it on me?! Doesnt deserve your business.

Very consistent and well worth the experience go and try it!