Definitely reminds me of the small town great pizza I grew up on out near Utica, and how Zamarelli’s was when we 1st moved to the area in the 90’s. They didnt go light on the sauce and you just have to know what you want. This this isnt a Massey’s/Donato’s/Classic’s style with edge to to edge pepperoni. Order extra pep like I did and I always order extra cheese from every place. The pepperoni seems thicker which I really, really like.This is definitely one of my new favorites, I hope it stays around for a long time. I ordered within an our of closing and they took my order with no problems, I appreciate that especially after I had a long difficult 70hr work week and a birthday immediately after for my kids where. I got to enjoy this all by myself peacefully. Thanks for filling up my belly!Always have to eat a corner slice on my way home from getting pizza. My late momma did it when we were growing, up so its always a salute to her when I do it now.
Isn't the same as in the past. I'm sure it's probably the same as in every other business. it's Coronavirus fault low staffed and cuts on ingredients
We're from London, Ohio, it's so nice to have found a genuine home town PIZZA place. Your like the old town pizzas our parents would get way back. Either Friday's or Monday's we order the best sandwiches and or pizzasWe drive thur to see our very dear friend's and get pizza for dinner for all of us. They're an older couple and now we have to drive them out ... they love your food and the sweetest people you have working.Thank you so much its nice to know your out thereCraig & Ginger
Very good pizza. Very good service!!
Nice folks there. Good lasagne and huge portions.
There pizza was great but I have had better to be honest
It was good I would've rather bought grandmas but ppl are nice price was high too but I get it nothing around soo
It has been a long time since I had Cattleman's Pizza! Omg, it was as good as it was the first time!! Definitely recommend Cattleman's Pizza!!
I found 2 cockroaches on my pizza they refused my money back do not go here they need shut down!!
Best pizza I drive from Columbus well worth it