Signatures Mill Stone Tavern

94 Mill St, Gahanna - 43230
213 reviews
Family Pizza
(614) 532-0344

Amara is THE GREATEST! She always knows what we need and takes care of everything in the moment. She is responsive and attentive to our party every time.

Been here over 40 minutes and have not been waited on .. was inside then move outside on the patio. Finally had to get our own drinks. Finishing our drinks and leaving!

Very nice place for drinks and good tavern food.

Very nice place. Great food (I recommend the Blues Burger and onion rings) our waitress was extremely wonderful (i think her name was Noah or Noelle) she was great with handling our crowd

Place reopened not to long ago. It is totally remodeled. Great draft beer, bottle beer and plenty of liquor choices. I had their meatball sub and it was pretty good. If they revisit the bread selection for the sandwich, it can be alot better. I can't wait to try the other food items.

Don't live around here but was in the area and decided to give this place a try and boy am I glad I did. Our waitress what is very friendly and answered my questions about the types of bourbon and I cannot believe the selections they have. The food which we had burgers and buffalo chicken sandwich and the onion rings are fabulous! Would definitely go back again!

My wife and I decided to come to trivia night tonight to enjoy some trivia with Rick Knight and Rick was the only good part of our experience.This was our first time coming to Signature’s and was probably the worst service we’ve received from any Gahanna establishment. We were barely acknowledged when we sat at the bar, by the bartender Amara, and had to get her attention after several minutes to order drinks. This continued throughout our time at the bar and our second and third rounds were served to us by someone else, maybe a manager. Amara was tending to other customers around us, next to us but never asking us if we needed anything.We wanted to like coming to Signature’s but after this experience and the dismissiveness of the bartender, we will likely never go there again.

The old establishment was so much better then current.I realize that there are new owners but they have more drinks then they do food. They have so many wines.I do like the way that they remodeled the restaurant.They are saying that they are going to be adding to the menu after the first of the year. I will go back to see what changes they have added.

Delicious pizza, great atmosphere. We were there on a live music night - so fun.

I'm really sad. Signatures is where my boyfriend and I met. We used to go at least once a week and we were really sad when it closed down. We've been back 3 times in person since they reopened. It looks so much better inside! We miss the popcorn. But no big deal. First time our service was great but our food was not. Second time our food was great but the service was terrible. Third time we sat for 30 minutes without being greeted and just left. Today we ordered pick up and our food was wrong again. We talked with the owner and he apologized the first visit. Second visit we spoke with a manager. I really wanted to love this place again.