Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern

73 N Hamilton Rd, Gahanna - 43230
323 reviews
American Pubs Comfort Food
(614) 475-4435

A friend and I were getting together to catch up after a long time. We were chatty and not looking at the menu. Sat longer than we should have. We did order food and drinks but our server was awesome. She didn't rush us and was super nice about us taking up space in her section. It wasn't super busy so I'm sure she didn't mind but it was nice.

We like to go here right after work for Happy Hour. Good food selection and reasonable prices.

Ate in the screened porch. So comfortable. Great experience!

Always a good place go for easy dinner. Be sure to make a reservation ahead of time. Makes it a lot easier.

Was somewhat disappointed last night with are meals , which is unusual . My husbands salmon wasn’t as good as it has been in the past . I had peel and eat shrimp , not sure who is cleaning the shrimp or if it comes in already done . But it was not all deveined , yuk ! All places have bad nights , so we will continue to go there .

Took the family out and we had great food and service

Party of 6 attended. Three ordered salads which seemed wilted. We could not spear the lettuce with our forks and had to scoop it up in order to eat it. However The waitress outstanding.

Good food at reasonable prices; outstanding service.

It is our most favorite place to eat. Met with our Son and Daughter in Law had such a good time she has been ill and finally got to get out with them. The waitress was such a special young lady. Made us feel at home You do a great job on everything you do with the restaurant. We will be back. Sue Mitchell

Service was terrific. I never had to ask for a diet refill. I ordered my absolute go to favorite the Blackened Salmon Salad. I always request that my salmon be cooked very well done and it was cooked perfectly. I usually order dressing to be on the side but not with this salad. The honey vinaigrette is amazing. I was incredibly disappointed that most of the ingredients that make this salad do special were not put on. There was plenty of avocado - no spinach no shaved fennel no shaved Brussels sprouts no goat cheese no candied pistachios ( hence no crunch ) and one bitty piece of kale. If they did have the ingredients to make it properly they could have said so .