So, 4 of my out of town friends tried this with me last week. There was one server seating, bringing drinks, taking orders, clearing tables, and closing out bills. On top of this, the salads were made with bagged lettuce and food wasn't hot. The good part? The good part, two of the 5 appetizers were very good. Unfortunately , we won't go back after this experience.
Best Italian food and service I've had in a very long time. I've had two visits to here and each was amazing. Food came out quick and was served piping hot. Great prices and big serving sizes (especially the lasagna). Definitely will be returning for many more visits. Also love that it is a local family run restaurant that takes great pride in their restaurant.
Food was amazing, Garlic bread was good & Lasagna was huge. It was busy but worth the wait. Be kind, curious & make a reservation if going on Friday or weekend night. Our Waitress/Owner was fabulous & all of the staff kept their cool with how busy it was. Will definitely be going back!!
Our 2nd day in Findlay and our 1st time at Preteroti’s. Love this place already! Excellent food and very friendly service! And the music is incredible for a romantic dinner ❤️ Highly highly recommend!
Such a perfect little Italian restaurant!!! Generous portions, everything was delicious! Superb service and excellent desserts! We will definitely be back. Thank you for a wonderful Valentine's dinner! To whomever said it was better then Olive Garden thank you for the referral, its a thousand times better. ?
Their spaghetti either the normal order or the Big Bambino is absolutely amazing. Their bread literally melts in your mouth it’s so good, it’s both savory and sweet. Anytime I have gotten food from Preteroti’s it has been amazing and i’ve always had amazing and kind service. Would eat here all the time, if it wasn’t for the needy demand of animals, and the draining cost of bills on my bank account.
Second time visiting so had to update my first review with pictures. Absolutely delicious. Food is even better than our first visit. Staff are lovely and kind. Definitely worth the wait and money. Authentic Italian food. We got calamari, pizza bites, chicken Parmesan, saccottini, and tiramisu for dessert. Definitely will go again. 100% recommend this place.
I give the food 4-5 stars. I give our service 1-2 stars. We understood they like everyone were probably short staffed, so we didn't get upset about our food taking just a bit over an hour. But we had to ask about our appetizers, which were forgotten as well as our salads. We watched other tables get great service from the other waitress in there. We will be excited to give it another try when they can either get their staffing beefed up or get good servers. It's a little to far for us (45min) for sub par service. Like I said though, the food was good though! Hoping it was just our visit.
Delicious food, fast friendly service. Nice atmosphere.
Alright friends.. if you're looking for a delicious, affordable Italian meal, do yourself a favor and go to Preteroti's Spaghetti House in Findlay. Went there tonight and took home spaghetti and meatballs, chicken alfredo, and garlic bread with a side salad. It was the best Italian I've had in a long time and it was under $30!