Pieology Pizzeria Findlay/Independent Square

1123 W Trenton Ave, Findlay - 45840
33 reviews
Pizza Fast Food
(567) 250-8114

We went to Pieology for the first time yesterday and it was phenomenal! The staff were super friendly and patient with us while we figured out what options we wanted, and the pizzas were amazing. Not your typical greasy quick pizza, but freshly baked and delicious. Our 3 year old son loved the pizza too. Would definitely recommend - I think it’s my new favorite pizza spot in town!

This is my new favorite pizza place! The pizzas are fresh baked and delicious without being greasy. The interior is very cool and fun and the booths are super comfortable. We had the bbq chicken thin crust and cheese thick crust pizzas and it was so good! Even my 3 yo son loved the pizza. Definitely will be going back!

Update on my FIRST reviewFirst visit wasn't so good in the first open week of business and I did get a nice response from management on my poor review I did tell them that I would be back for a second try at a later date.Today was the day and I was pleasantly surprised to see that the manager David was there ( we know David from another restaurant in Findlay) and he handled our order from start to cutting a great choice by the owner here to hire him we ordered thin, heavy sauce, extra mozzarella, shaved parmesan, pepperoni,, sausage, hot sausage and we'll done ( pepperoni cupping) experience helps and we are happy with our choices here thanks David

Tonight we were here during a rush. A softball team had arrived. The staff handled the rush with amazing skill and kept everyone moving! Great job and the food was amazing as always

What a fun lunch experience! The atmosphere was clean & bright. The pizza was delicious! Looking forward to taking the family here for dinner.

This place is great, with fresh ingredients and well cooked pizza!The staff was friendly and the place was very clean, no pizza grease on anything.When we moved here from Michigan I was missing a similar joint that offered toppings a la carte. Now I don't have to as this is a suitable replacement!Its fun to build different combinations and experiment with flavors. It's like having a pizza lab right around the corner.You should patronize this place so they stay in business! We need more places like this in the area.

I've eaten here twice and both times were great experiences! The decor is creative, the restaurant is spacious and clean, and the staff are very friendly! They cut half of my pizza into triangles and the other half in rectangles which I thought was really cute ?

Pieology is honestly one of the best pizza places I've ever been to. The staff is really very friendly and sweet, they actually seem to enjoy their jobs! There's a wide array of toppings for building your own pizza, and the price was surprisingly fair considering how expensive takeout is post-COVID. Plus - they have vegan cheese AND meat options with the daiya cheese and the vegan 'meatballs' and Italian sausage! The atmosphere is nice too, in the event you feel like dining in. Very relaxing and clean atmosphere!If you live close, consider making this place your new favorite pizza spot.

Connor was amazing and handle 3 of our orders, all very different, amazingly. He showed great customer service and was very prompt. The only reason it is not a 5 star review is because of his shift leader was very rude to him and kept trying to correct him on our orders, even though he was doing everything how we had asked him. He made great conversation and made us feel welcomed. So 5 stars for Connor, no stars for his rude supervisor (Carol)

I usually have a hard time trying new places to eat but it was worth taking the chance at Pieology! I had a great experience here. The ingredients were very fresh with a ton of great options. They have an updated Coca-Cola machine that is always fun to use and make your own blend of soft drink.The whole place was extremely clean and well organized. Chairs were set neatly at every table and counter and there was no trash or grime to be seen.The manager that made my order was totally on his A-game. He delivered it to my table when it was finished baking and even had a to go box ready before I even had to ask him.This place has a great vibe and would make a great night out with family or friends.