Penn Station East Coast Subs

2025 Tiffin Ave #2, Findlay - 45480
78 reviews
Sandwich Shop
(567) 525-4506

The best corned beef sub I've ever had. It was cooked perfectly.

The sandwich leaked through the paper and the bag. Tasted good, but made a mess in my car.

Standard Penn Station. Food is good, the place could use more attention to cleanliness.

Seemed like everyone who was working was to high to understand the words coming out of my mouth, they messed up both my subs, I asked for sauteed onions and no mushrooms instead they gave me extra mushrooms no sauteed onions I also asked for my chicken cordon bleu to have no honey mustard or tomatoes and they kept the honey mustard and tomatoes on. Their hours are changed at the moment but they have not post it anywhere the change hours they have out a olive oil but their food is actually made in a peanut butter is soy mix and they do it don't have it posted anywhere so it is not peanut allergy friendly

These new people at the one on tiffin ave in Findlay are rude and don't know how to make subs. I ordered 4 and only one turned out the way it was ordered the others either we asked for light mustard and got smothered in mustard or asked for oil and vinegar and they didn't even put it on it then they made the 3 cold subs toasted ? very disappointed ill just go back to firehouse were i know ill get what i ordered.

Amazing subs nice change up from other shops in the area.

Woman working in front always nice

Very great subs! Super hot and fresh, employees polite and got everything correct. Love it.

I went in to pick up food and employes were rude and not very friendly. Paid for my online order and waited for 5 minutes while employees just talked and did nothing when my food was ready behind them. I had to ask for them to give me my food. Then the sandwich was wrong so I returned to just try to get it remade and I was met with hostility from 2 employees ( 1 being a manager) saying that I had said "choice words to a employees) no one could tell me what I said that was wrong. Then they got in my face and said they would not remake my food. Terrible employees won't be coming back.

To expensive and the quality of the sub was terrible and hardly anything on the sub and all bun,on the brite side the fresh squeeze lemonade was good.